Skip to main content
. 2016 Feb 6;7(2):24. doi: 10.3390/mi7020024

Table 3.

Relevant work on micromirrors with electrothermal actuators.

Reference Year Size (in mm) Characteristics Operating Conditions Natural Frequency
Buser et al. [104] 1992 - 180 mW -
Buhler et al. [105] 1995 0.035 × 0.04 4.5° - -
Schweizer et al. [101] 1999 - 90° 1 mW 330 Hz
Schweizer et al. [100] 2000 - 30° 5 mW 220 Hz
Pan et al. [106] 2001 - 15° - 165 Hz
Xie et al. [38] 2002 1 × 1 mirror 32° optical 12 mA -
Xie et al. [128] 2003 1 × 1 mirror 35° optical 7 mA -
Xie et al. [116] 2003 1 × 1 mirror 32° optical 12 mA 165 Hz
Xie et al. [118] 2003 1 × 1 mirror 37° optical 7 mA -
Jain et al. [119] 2004 1 × 1 mirror 64° and 33° (2R) 8 mA 259 Hz
Jain et al. [123] 2005 0.7 × 0.32 (0.19 mirror) 26.5°, ±15, 200 μm 6 V 1.18 kHz
Todd et al. [127] 2006 0.5 × 0.5 mirror 56 μm - -
Jiang et al. [107] 2006 50 μm cantilever 300 nm 0.2 V 117 kHz
Henneken et al. [99] 2006 2 mm length 13 μm 45 V -
Jain et al. [125] 2006 0.5 × 0.5 mirror ±30° (2R), 500 μm 12 V 170 Hz
Singh et al. [110] 2008 1 × 1 17°, 250 μm 2 V -
Xu et al. [112] 2008 2.5 × 2.5 17° mech. 1.5 V 46 Hz cut-off
Wu et al. [126] 2008 2.5 × 2.5 0.7° tilt, 620 μm 5.3 V 500 Hz
Jia et al. [124] 2009 1 × 1 mirror ±30° (2R), 480 μm 8 V 336 Hz
Premachandran et al. [111] 2009 1.5 × 1.5 chip 16° - -
Wang et al. [113] 2010 1.5 × 1.5 11° 1.2 V 60 Hz
Sun et al. [121] 2010 - 30° (2R), 600 μm 5.5 V 13 Hz
Mu et al. [115] 2011 1 mm dia. mirror 11° 1.4 V 75 Hz
Pal et al. [109] 2011 1 mm dia. mirror 60° (2R) 0.6 V 104 Hz
Liu et al. [120] 2011 1.5 × 1.5 ±16° (2 layer flip) 3.6 V 659 Hz
Izhar et al. [122] 2011 4.5 die 1.3 32° optical, 131 μm 12 mW 10.5 Hz cut-off
Liu et al. [103] 2012 2 × 2 ±11°, 227 μm 0.6 V 197 Hz