Table 8.
Results of pairwise comparisons in Tones * Bands * Cue three-way repeated measures ANOVA on tone accuracy.
| No. | Background | Tone | Band | Cue order | Mean (SD) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ORI | TFS | TE500 | TE50 | |||||
| 1 | QUI | T1 | B04 | ORI = TFS>TE500>TE50a | 83% (26%) | 72% (29%) | 30% (32%) | 13% (31%) |
| 2 | B08 | ORI = TFS>TE500 = TE50a | 87% (17%) | 72% (35%) | 31% (35%) | 22% (30%) | ||
| 3 | B16 | ORI = TFS>TE50 = TE500a | 93% (14%) | 81% (21%) | 19% (26%) | 30% (34%) | ||
| 4 | T2 | B04 | ORI = TFS>TE500>TE50a | 83% (26%) | 81% (29%) | 50% (33%) | 24% (28%) | |
| 5 | B08 | TFS = ORI>TE500 = TE50a | 91% (15%) | 93% (14%) | 48% (33%) | 35% (42%) | ||
| 6 | B16 | ORI = TFS>TE500 = TE50a | 91% (19%) | 83% (24%) | 57% (34%) | 48% (37%) | ||
| 7 | T3 | B04 | ORI = TFS>TE500 = TE50a | 63% (34%) | 30% (32%) | 17% (26%) | ||
| 8 | B08 | TFS = ORI>TE500 = TE50a | 70% (30%) | 22% (20%) | 9% (19%) | |||
| 9 | B16 | ORI = TFS>TE500 = TE50a | 72% (33%) | 65% (27%) | 37% (23%) | 19% (23%) | ||
| 10 | T4 | B04 | ORI = TE500(= TE50)>(TE50 =)TFSa | 100% (0%) | 69% (18%) | 98% (8%) | 83% (26%) | |
| 11 | B08 | ORI = TE500 = TE50>TFSa | 98% (8%) | 61% (21%) | 98% (8%) | 89% (16%) | ||
| 12 | B16 | ORI = TE500 = TE50>TFS a | 96% (11%) | 48% (21%) | 94% (13%) | 87% (20%) | ||
| 13 | T5 | B04 | TFS = ORI>TE500 = TE50a | 89% (26%) | 28% (29%) | 9% (15%) | ||
| 14 | B08 | TFS = ORI>TE500 = TE50a | 83% (21%) | 91% (19%) | 24% (28%) | 13% (20%) | ||
| 15 | B16 | TFS = ORI>TE500 = TE50a | 83% (26%) | 85% (26%) | 22% (23%) | 15% (21%) | ||
| 16 | T6 | B04 | ORI(= TFS)>(TFS =)(= TE500)>(TE500 =)TE50a | 39% (33%) | 22% (28%) | 7% (14%) | 0% (0%) | |
| 17 | B08 | ORI(= TFS)>(TFS =)(= TE50)>(TE50 =)TE500a | 46% (28%) | 24% (25%) | 4% (11%) | 7% (18%) | ||
| 18 | B16 | ORI>TFS = TE50 = TE500a | 41% (33%) | 7% (14%) | 4% (11%) | 4% (11%) | ||
| 19 | SSN | T1 | B04 | TFS = ORI>TE500 = TE50a | 80% (20%) | 87% (23%) | 17% (29%) | 9% (19%) |
| 20 | B08 | ORI = TFS>TE500 = TE50a | 81% (23%) | 74% (18%) | 22% (30%) | 13% (23%) | ||
| 21 | B16 | ORI = TFS>TE50 = TE500a | 76% (25%) | 70% (23%) | 19% (26%) | 35% (37%) | ||
| 22 | T2 | B04 | ORI = TFS>TE500 = TE50a | 69% (29%) | 56% (36%) | 22% (23%) | 13% (17%) | |
| 23 | B08 | ORI = TFS>TE50 = TE500a | 67% (23%) | 61% (26%) | 22% (26%) | 22% (20%) | ||
| 24 | B16 | ORI(= TFS)>(TFS =)(= TE500)>(TE500 =)TE50a | 67% (34%) | 48% (31%) | 28% (31%) | 20% (23%) | ||
| 25 | T3 | B04 | ORI = TFS>TE50 = TE500a | 72% (33%) | 69% (31%) | 22% (20%) | 22% (32%) | |
| 26 | B08 | ORI = TFS>TE500 = TE50a | 78% (30%) | 70% (32%) | 28% (26%) | 20% (26%) | ||
| 27 | B16 | ORI = TFS>TE500 = TE50a | 80% (33%) | 67% (23%) | 22% (26%) | 7% (18%) | ||
| 28 | T4 | B04 | ORI(= TFS)>(TFS =)(= TE500)>(TE500 =)TE50a | 98% (8%) | 83% (24%) | 74% (22%) | 56% (26%) | |
| 29 | B08 | ORI>TE500 = TFS = TE50a | 98% (8%) | 59% (24%) | 74% (22%) | 54% (28%) | ||
| 30 | B16 | ORI>TE500(= TE50)>(TE50 =)TFSa | 100% (0%) | 43% (22%) | 80% (28%) | 56% (32%) | ||
| 31 | T5 | B04 | TFS = ORI>TE500 = TE50a | 74% (29%) | 74% (29%) | 17% (24%) | 15% (23%) | |
| 32 | B08 | ORI = TFS>TE500 = TE50a | 80% (31%) | 52% (37%) | 20% (26%) | 13% (17%) | ||
| 33 | B16 | ORI = TFS>TE500 = TE50a | 65% (35%) | 54% (31%) | 26% (22%) | 20% (23%) | ||
| 34 | T6 | B04 | ORI(= TFS)>(TFS =)(= TE500)>(TE500 =)TE50a | 39% (37%) | 30% (25%) | 9% (15%) | 6% (13%) | |
| 35 | B08 | ORI = TFS>TE50 = TE500a | 35% (35%) | 33% (26%) | 7% (14%) | 7% (14%) | ||
| 36 | B16 | ORI(= TFS)>(TFS =)TE500 = TE50a | 30% (28%) | 24% (28%) | 7% (18%) | 4% (11%) | ||
| 37 | 2MB | T1 | B04 | ORI = TFS>TE50 = TE500b | 80% (23%) | 72% (24%) | 9% (19%) | 17% (29%) |
| 38 | B08 | ORI = TFS>TE500 = TE50b | 80% (23%) | 76% (30%) | 17% (26%) | 15% (29%) | ||
| 39 | B16 | ORI>TFS>TE500 = TE50b | 78% (23%) | 48% (33%) | 20% (23%) | 11% (20%) | ||
| 40 | T2 | B04 | ORI = TFS>TE500 = TE50b | 80% (38%) | 76% (28%) | 20% (28%) | 11% (16%) | |
| 41 | B08 | ORI>TFS>TE500 = TE50b | 83% (17%) | 65% (24%) | 22% (26%) | 20% (28%) | ||
| 42 | B16 | ORI(= TFS)>(TFS =)TE50 = TE500b | 69% (21%) | 48% (26%) | 17% (17%) | 19% (33%) | ||
| 43 | T3 | B04 | ORI = TFS>TE50 = TE500b | 74% (24%) | 65% (29%) | 15% (21%) | 19% (23%) | |
| 44 | B08 | ORI = TFS>TE500 = TE50b | 70% (30%) | 56% (30%) | 17% (24%) | 11% (20%) | ||
| 45 | B16 | ORI = TFS = TE500>TE50b | 46% (36%) | 39% (29%) | 31% (24%) | 11% (20%) | ||
| 46 | T4 | B04 | ORI>TFS = TE500>TE50b | 98% (8%) | 80% (23%) | 70% (25%) | 33% (30%) | |
| 47 | B08 | ORI>TFS = TE50 = TE500b | 98% (8%) | 70% (25%) | 56% (28%) | 61% (31%) | ||
| 48 | B16 | ORI(= TE500)>(TE500 =)TE50>TFSb | 96% (11%) | 22% (23%) | 83% (24%) | 72% (26%) | ||
| 49 | T5 | B04 | TFS = ORI>TE500 = TE50b | 80% (26%) | 81% (23%) | 19% (21%) | 15% (17%) | |
| 50 | B08 | TFS(= ORI = TE50)>(ORI = TE50 =)TE500b | 50% (38%) | 59% (31%) | 20% (23%) | 22% (20%) | ||
| 51 | B16 | TFS = ORI>TE50 = TE500b | 59% (27%) | 61% (29%) | 26% (27%) | 26% (29%) | ||
| 52 | T6 | B04 | 39% (24%) | 24% (23%) | 7% (9%) | 7% (9%) | ||
| 53 | B08 | ORI >TFS>TE500 = TE50c | ||||||
| 54 | B16 | |||||||
mark “ORI = TFS>TE500 = TE50,” with ORI and TFS, and TE500 and TE50 in any order.
mark ORI significantly better than TFS, TE500 and TE50.
mark TFS as the worst.
mark TE50 as the worst.
Unformatted cells mark other orders.
Bold cells mark chance accuracy (17%) or below.
For QUI and SSN, orders of Cues in each band were reported because of the insignificant three-way Cues * Bands * Tones interactions, and the significant two-way Cues * Bands and Cues * Tones interactions (Table 3).