Skip to main content
. 2018 Oct 23;18:274. doi: 10.1186/s12886-018-0945-5

Table 2.

Assessment of potential bias in included studies

Year First author Bias in selection of cases Bias in selection of controls Bias in genotyping controls Bias in population stratification Confounding bias Multiple test and Selective outcome reports
2007 Yate et al. [54] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2007 Maller et al. [41] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2008 Edwards et al. [31] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2008 Spencer et al. [50] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2009 Scholl et al. [4] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2009 Francis et al. [32] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2009 Park et al. [44] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2009 Despriet et al. [30] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2009 Bergeron et al. [22] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2009 Reynolds et al. [47] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2009 Pei et al. [45] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2010 Cui et al. [29] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2010 Zerbib et al. [56] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2010 McKay et al. [43] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2010 Chen et al. [25] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2010 Kopplin et al. [37] NO NO NO Unclear NO NO
2010 Liu et al. [39] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2011 Yu et al. [55] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2011 Chen et al. [26] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2011 Hageman et al. [33] NO NO NO Unclear NO NO
2011 Peter et al. [46] Yes NO NO Unclear NO NO
2011 Yanagisawa et al. [53] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2012 Martinez et al. [42] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2012 Smailhodzic et al. [49] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2012 Buentello et al. [23] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2012 Tian et al. [51] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2012 Losonczy et al. [40] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2012 Cipriani et al. [27] NO Yes NO NO NO NO
2012 Jaouni et al. [36] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2013 Wu et al. [52] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2013 Helgason et al. [35] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2014 Contreras et al. [28] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2014 Caire et al. [24] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2014 Liu et al. [38] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2015 Hautamaki et al. [34] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2016 Saksens et al. [48] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2017 Bonyadi et al. [20, 21] NO NO NO NO NO NO
2017 Habibi et al. [57] NO NO NO NO NO NO