Table 4:
Comparison of the NIST Study to previous MRI studies on OAB
| Previous MRI studies on OAB | NIST neuroimaging studies |
|---|---|
| Almost exclusively on women | Men and women (target 1:1 ratio) |
| Almost exclusively focused on patients with UUI and/or detrusor overactivity (DO) | Recruit urgency with UUI, and urgency without UUI (target 1:1 ratio) |
| Most studies have small sample size (n≤20) | Large sample size (n>250) permits evaluation of patient subgroups. NIST is the largest study of its kind |
| Primarily single center studies | Multi-center study across the US, with geographically diverse group of patients |
| Many studies have no control groups for Comparison | Age and sex matched control group (target cases: control ratio = 2:1) |
| Participants may be community subjects with OAB symptoms | Participants are clinic patients seeking evaluation and treatment of OAB |
| Participants were catheterized and filled inside the scanner (invasive, may sensitize the bladder, urethra or pelvic floor, and confound brain signals) | No bladder catheterization |
| Rapid, repeated, alternating cycles of bladder filling and emptying to elicit BOLD fMRI signals (non-physiologic, does not reproduce clinical urgency) | Bladder is filled by natural diuresis after water consumption. |
| Most previous studies have used BOLD functional MRI to study activation and deactivation of specific brain regions | Advanced multi-modal techniques (RS-fcMRI, DTI, T1) are used to understand functional connectivity, structural connectivity, and gray matter volume. |
| Isolated functional MRI studies | Integration with detailed phenotyping data available through the LURN Observational Cohort Study (clinical, questionnaires, and biosample).[18] Comprehensive integrationof MRI data with quantitative sensory testing (QST) data to assess CNS roles in urgency. |