Table 3.
Study | Health condition | Comparison | Main outcome [Instrument] | Outcomea [follow-up]b | 95% CI |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bauer et al. (2012) | Bulimia Nervosa | Guided text messaging intervention vs. TAU | Remission rates [LIFE] |
RR = 1.42c [8 months] |
0.99; 2.02 |
Fichter et al. (2012) | Anorexia Nervosa (AN) | Internet-based guided self- help vs. TAU | Body Mass Index [BMI] |
d = −0.19d [9 months] |
−0.08; 0.46 |
Gulec et al. (2014) | Bulimia Nervosa/EDNOS | Internet-based guided self-help vs. TAU | Severity of eating disorder [EDE-Q] |
d = −0.28d [4 months] |
−0.73; 0.18 |
Jacobi et al. (2017) | Bulimia Nervosa (BN) | Internet-based guided self- help vs. TAU | abstinence from core symptoms of BN [SIAB-EX] |
OR = 1.29 [9 months] OR = 1.49 [18 months] |
0.68; 2.44 0.77; − 2.86 |
Holländare et al. (2011) | Depression | Internet-based guided self- help vs. TAU | Relapse rates [SCID] |
RR = 0.28 [6 months] RR = 0.24 [24 months]e |
0.10; 0.77 0.10; 0.55 |
Kordy et al. (2016) | Recurrent depression | Internet-based guided intervention vs. unguided intervention vs. TAU | Transition from to ‘well’ to ‘unwell’ [LIFE] | unguided: RR = 0.91 [12 months] RR = 0.69 [24 months] guided: RR = 1.11 [12 months] RR = 0.92 [24 months] |
0.51; 1.64 0.44; 1.09 0.63; 1.95 0.59; 1.43 |
Kraft et al. (2017) | Depression | Text message self-help vs. TAU | Severity of depressive symptoms [PHQ-9] |
d = −0.45 [4 months] |
−1.11; −0.23 |
Norlund et al. (2018) | Myocardial Infarction (comorbid depressive/anxiety symptoms) |
Web-based guided self- help vs. TAU | Severity of depression and anxiety [HADS-T] |
d = −0.13 [14 weeks] |
−0.38; 0.13 |
Schmädeke and Bischoff (2015) | Depression | Mobile-based self-help vs. TAU | Severity of depression symptoms [BDI] |
d = −0.08 [3 months] |
−0.49; 0.33 |
Zwerenz et al. (2017a) | Depression | Web-based self-help vs. attention control website | depressive symptoms [BDI-II] |
d = −0.44 [6 months] |
−0.71; −0.17 |
Bischoff et al. (2013) | Transdiagnostic | Mobile-based self-help vs. phone contact | Work-related Behaviour and Experience Patterns [AVEM] |
d = 0.18 [6 months] d = 0.08 [12 months] |
−0.21; 0.56 −0.32; 0.48 |
Ebert et al. (2013) | Transdiagnostic | Web-based guided self- help vs. TAU | general psychopathological symptom severity [HEALTH-49] |
d = −0.38c [3 months] d = −0.44c [12 months] |
−0.18; −0.58 −0.64; −0.24 |
Välimäki et al. (2017) | Transdiagnostic | Text message self-help vs. TAU | patient readmission to psychiatric hospital [Finnish national Care Register for Health Care (HILMO)] |
RR = 1.11 [12 months] |
0.92; 1.33 |
Willems et al. (2017a) | Cancer (transdiagnostic) | Web-based self-help vs. WLCG+TAU | Various, e.g. depression [PHQ-9] |
d = −0.21 [6 months] d = −0.10 [12 months]f |
−0.40; −0.01 −0.30; 0.11 |
Zwerenz et al. (2017b) | Transdiagnostic | Web-based guided self-help vs. WLCG | Various, e.g. depression [PHQ-9] |
d = −0.34c [10 weeks] |
−0.81; 0.14 |
Zwerenz et al. (2017a) | Transdiagnostic | Web-based guided self-help vs. TAU | subjective prognosis of work ability [SPE] |
d = −0.13 [3 months] d = −0.20 [12 months] |
−0.28; 0.03 −0.36; −0.04 |
Note. Own calculations based on study data. EDNOS: Eating disorder not otherwise specified; OR: Odd's ratio; RR: Risk ratio; TAU: Treatment as usual; WLCG: Waitlist control group. Abbreviations of measurement instruments can be found in Appendix D.
Note. Own calculations based on study data. EDNOS: Eating disorder not otherwise specified; OR: Odd's ratio; RR: Risk ratio; TAU: Treatment as usual; WLCG: Waitlist control group. Abbreviations of measurement instruments can be found in Appendix D.
Between-group comparisons.
Post-treatment- and latest available follow-up.
ITT-analyses.
Unpublished age stratified data provided by PI.
Additional publication: Holländare et al. (2013).
Additional publication: Willems et al. (2017b).