TABLE 1.
Authors & Year | Age (yrs), Sex |
Triggers | HG Depth Electrode |
Ictal Onset Zone | Resection Extent | Outcome (Engel class) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Trevathan et al., 1999 | 43, M | Specific theme songs |
No | Rt STG | Rt temporal lesionectomy |
I |
Tayah et al., 2006 | 20, F | Popular music rhythms |
No | Rt lateral neocortical temporal |
Rt ATL, spared hippocampus |
I |
24, F | Listen/play emotional songs |
Yes (3 depth electrodes) |
Rt mesial temporal | Rt ATL | I | |
19, F | Emotional church hymns & store music |
No | Bilat mesial temporal, independently |
No resection | NA | |
Mehta et al., 2009 | 24, F | Rhythmic music | Yes | Rt mesial temporal | Rt ATL | I |
Duanyu et al., 2010 | 16, M | Popular rhythms, singing more effective |
No | Lt STG (middle portion) | Lt superior temporal topectomy |
II |
Wang et al., 2012 | 42, M | Specific songs | Yes (w/ a PT depth electrode) |
Lt PT | Lt tailored STG resection |
I |
Tezer et al., 2014 | 33, F | Affective music in native language |
No | Bilat hippocampus (rt, musicogenic; lt, spontaneous) |
No resection (VNS was placed) |
II |
Klamer et al., 2015 | 22, M | Rap music | No | Rt mesial temporal | Rt ATL | II |
Stern, 2015 | 46, F | Various musical genres |
No | Rt mesial & superior temporal |
Rt ATL | I |
NA = not applicable; VNS = vagal nerve stimulator.