Table 2.
*Source | Country Source | Sampled Population with N | Perspective Studied | Methods | Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Abu-Zaid et al. 2014 [54] | Saudi- Arabia | 116/171 female medical students | Perceived barriers | -Online, self-rating survey, using Likert scale | -Top three barriers identified: Greater preference for patient care than research (75.0%); Work/life balance (52.6%); and lack of female role models (48.3%). |
Abu-Zaid, 2014 [14] | Saudi-Arabia | 61 female second year undergraduate medical students | Perceived attitudes | -Cross-sectional, self-rating survey | −31.1% had previous summer research experiences (68.0% local and 33.0% international programs). -All showed positive attitudes towards undergraduate research. - 72.0% endorsed the importance and 44.0% the compulsoriness of integrating scientific research into undergraduate medical education curricula. |
Al-Halabi, 2014 [15] | Kuwait | 150 sixth and seventh year medical students | Experiences, attitudes, and barriers | -Questionnaire | −66.0% of the students had participated in research. -54.0% students read medical journals regularly. -Barriers included: Lack of time due to other commitments or studies (33.9%), lack of interest either by the participant or other members of his/her project group (27.4%), lack of guidance and supervision (16.1%), lack of encouragement from the project’s mentor (12.1%), and lack of knowledge on how to write a scientific article for publication (10.5%). -42.0% of the students believed that research is important during undergraduate education, while 77.3% believed that it will become important during their future career. |
Anbari et al. 2015 [58] | Iran | 627 students in six schools of medical sciences | Barriers and infrastructure | -Quantitative and qualitative analytical approaches. - Research vs non-research groups -Barriers were validated using the Delphi technique on 36 students. |
- Research students reported institutional barriers such as time, lack of access to electronic resources and prolongation of the process of buying equipment. -Non-research students reported individual barriers including lack of time, scientific writing skills, and access to trained assistants. |
Baig, 2013 [33] | Pakistan | 398 medical students at four medical universities | Perceptions, Prior experience and future research intent | -Data collection tool using a questionnaire and open-ended questions. | −88% intended to do research prior to medical school but only 51% reported they had previous research experience. -Reasons for engaging in research were to improve curriculum vitae (75%) and increase competitiveness for residency in the USA (43%). |
Burgoyne, 2010 [16] | United Kingdom | 317 undergraduate medical students | Transferable and research skills, prior research experience, attitude and motivation | -Questionnaire | −81% reported unawareness of opportunities. -51% expressed interest in research career. -56.5% reported moderate motivation, 35.8% high motivation, and 7.7% low motivation. -Barriers included: Isolation from friends (9%), felt like it was overly challenging or uninteresting (13%), undecided (11%). |
Carter, 2016 [20] | United States (U.S) | 266/346 osteopathic medical students | Research experience, interest during medical school | -Questionnaire | −81% had prior research experience. -75% had interest during medical school. -82% favored clinical research. |
de Oliveira et al. 2011 [17] | Brazil | 1004 medical students from 13 medical programs | -Availability and degree of involvement -Barriers |
-Questionnaire | −7% had no interest in research. - 60% of them were involved in research training. -Barriers: Lack of institutional incentive, defective infrastructure, insufficient time available for professors to mentor undergraduate students. |
Ejaz, 2011 [47] | Pakistan | 387 final year medical students and fresh graduates | Research involvement, interest and barriers | -Cross-sectional questionnaire | -Medical students results only: 49% conducted literature search, 65% had journal reading experience due to the requirement of their institution. 41% undergraduates had already participated in a research project, however, mostly in the field as data collectors or computer assistants. -Barriers included: Current research status and teachings of Pakistan to be inadequate. |
Funston et al. 2016 [48] | United Kingdom (UK) | 1625 responses from 38 countries (excluding US); analysis restricted to countries with > 100 responses (n = 890) | Perceptions | -Online questionnaire | -Less than 50% thought their institution provided adequate research training. -Key barriers were lack of time and mentors. -Females were less interested. -The barriers and satisfaction with research training differed significantly among countries. |
Jimmy, 2013 [29] | India | 114 medical students | Perception and benefits | -Cross sectional study: Questionnaires | −20.9% had publications. -81.7% saw research being essential to understanding. -38.3% thought it cumbersome. -24.3% of the students were involved in research purely for acquiring knowledge. -18.3% were pursuing interest in research, while 1.7% were doing research to improve their curriculum vitae. -73.9% found it essential for all students to do research. -Barriers found: Lack of time, lack of incentives in the form of scholarships, and post-graduate specialty selection. |
Kharraz et al. 2016 [55] | Saudi Arabia | 221/350 medical students. | Perceived barriers | -Online, cross-sectional, self-rating survey | -Participation significantly differed by gender (males vs. females): 68.6% vs. 45.4%. -Top three barriers: Lack of time (77.4%), lack of formal courses in curriculum (76%), and lack of UR mentors (70.1%). Others were lack of mentors, lack of interest in research, lack of finding same-gender research mentor, and lack of opportunities. |
Kumar, 2009 [40] | India | 471 medical students | Awareness, perceptions and practices | -Questionnaire-based qualitative study | −70% were aware about research although the level of awareness varied. -Various skills of conducting research were known to 47% of the students. -76% were part of a research team mainly as a part of the medical curriculum. -8.3% were confident of research as a career option. |
Mahmood, 2017 [4] | Pakistan | 294 medical students | -Current research practices. -Future intentions. -Related motivations, barriers, and sought-after interventions |
-Self-administered questionnaire | -Intentions to pursue research at a professional level remained low (19.7%). -Intentions decreased each passing year of study. -Most commonly expressed motivation for pursuing research was “admission into a residency program” (71.8%). -Such intention was associated with a decreased likelihood of pursing research professionally. -Barriers: Lack of time (72.4%), lack of supervisors (50.3%), lack of opportunity (48.3%). |
Meraj, 2016 [34] | Pakistan | 172 medical students | Perceptions and attitudes | -Cross-sectional questionnaire | −45.3% were aware of research opportunities. -65.7% thought research was important to future career and relevant to their lives -41.9% not interested in research as a career. -41.3% students enjoyed research -70% perceived research as stressful and 62.2% complex |
Mina et al., 2016 [32] | Saudi Arabia | 218/350 medical students | Perception and participation | -Online survey | -Top three influential factors: Facilitate entry into competitive residency programs (88.1%), improve curriculum vitae (81.2%), and publish in peer-reviewed journals (79.8%). -Participation in research significantly differed by gender, academic year, and GPA. |
Moraes, 2016 [27] | Brazil | 278 medical students from first to sixth year. | Interest in research | -Cross-sectional, self-administered questionnaire | −81.7% were interested in research. -Only 4.7% of the students thought research is important. -No statistically significant association with age, gender, number of physicians in their family, prior college courses were found. |
Nel et al., 2013 [30] | South Africa | 733 medical students | Attitudes | -Cross-sectional survey | −61% had positive attitudes toward research. -74% thought involvement is important -22% voluntarily engaged in research -4% presented at a meeting and 3% had published Perceived barriers: Lack of adequate training, time, and research opportunities. |
Oliveira, 2014 [49] | Brazil | 415 first through sixth year medical students | Understanding, advantages, difficulties and motivations | -Questionnaire | −47.2% were involved in research. -Main barrier reported was time constraint. -Among students not involved in research, 91.1% reported, however, that they favored its inclusion in the curriculum. |
O’ Sullivan, 2009 [50] | United States (U.S) | 40 medical students | Attitudes | -Qualitative based on interviews conducted in person at locations chosen by participant. | - Five (5) themes were reported: Early exposure to research, role models and mentoring, career pathways, interplay of personal and social factors, and career support for junior faculty members. |
Park et al., 2010 [35] | New Zealand | 558 medical students | Attitudes | -Questionnaire | −25% participated in some form of research activity, mostly in the summer, during medical school. -70% expressed interest in participating in research during medical school. -68% of respondents were aware of the intercalated research degree option but only 8.6% were interested. -35% of respondents planned to be involved in research throughout their medical career. -More students rated lifestyle (84% affirmative) and earning potential (43% affirmative) as more important factors than opportunity for research (23% affirmative) when choosing a career specialty. |
Pathipati, 2016 [31] | United States (U.S) | 328 medical students | Perception of research year | -Online survey at 5 medical schools with highly regarded research programs | -Reasons for research years off: Increase competitiveness for residency application (32%), time to pursue other opportunities (24%), and academic interest (23%). -Students who would still take a research year even if they were already assured a position in a residency program of their choice were at 65%, while 35% would not take a research year. |
Rosenkranz, 2015 [18] | Australia | 579/806 medical students from first year through fifth year | Attitudes, motivations, and barriers | -Convergent parallel mixed methods study using cross-sectional quantitative survey data and qualitative semi-structured interview findings | −7.5 % of students had prior research experience. -42% indicated interest beyond medical school. -89.1% of students believe conducting research is advantageous for medical career. -44.2% believe bureaucracy surrounding research is a significant deterrent. -49.8% of students were neutral to research and lower salary. |
Sheikh, 2013 [59] | Pakistan | 122 students | Interest and enthusiasm | -Case (not interested in research)-control (those interested) study | -Barriers identified by interested students: Curriculum overload, internet inexperience, an uncooperative community, difficulty in finding a mentor and selecting a topic, lack of previous exposure, and lack of internet facilities. -Barriers identified by non-interested students: sleep loss, extracurricular activities, uncooperative colleagues, inclement weather (hot and humid), lack of knowledge, bad past experiences, social commitments, drugs/addictions, laziness, uncooperative faculty, transportation problems, lack of motives and incentives, faculty-forced research, fatigue, and an attitude that considered research useless. |
Siemens, 2010 [51] | Canada | 327 second and fourth year medical students at three medical schools. | Attitudes and experience | -Questionnaire | -Involved in research prior to medical school (87%). -43% were not significantly involved in research during medical school. -24% were not interested. -44% believed research is important in future career. -Barriers included: Time, availability of research mentors, lack of formal teaching of research methodology, and lack of appropriate acknowledgement. |
Stockfelt, 2016 [19] | Sweden | 471 medical students | Research interest and activity | -Questionnaire administered as a follow up to a 2006 survey | −16% were actively involved in research. -36% were interested. -Barriers to research included: Lack of time (23%), excessive workload (22%), and not enough time to study (16%). -Financial compensation, expansion of research opportunities, and career planning would aid in research interest. |
*Brackets denotes the number in the reference list.