Table 4.
Intervention studies with parallel design assessing the effects of chronic intake of diets with different GI on body weight 1.
Study | Sample | Duration | Intervention | Treatment Effects (Low vs. High GI) |
Greater Fiber (Low GI) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Buscemi et al. [38] |
40 obese adults 20–60 years 25–49.9 kg/m2 |
3 months | LGI diet, hypocaloric HGI diet, hypocaloric |
↔ Weight loss ↔ WC ↔ BMI |
No |
Philippou et al. [39] |
18 adults at risk for heart disease 35–65 years 27–35 kg/m2 |
12 weeks | LGI diet HGI diet Deficit 500 kcal/day |
↔ Weight loss ↔ BMI |
No |
Abete et al. [40] |
32 obese Spanish adults 36 ± 7 years 32.5 ± 4.3 kg/m2 |
8 weeks | LGI diet HGI diet 30% energy restriction |
↓ Body weight | Yes |
Das et al. [23] |
34 overweight adults 24–42 years 25–30 kg/m2 |
12 months | LGL diet HGL diet 30% energy restriction |
↔ Weight loss, % Body fat ↔ Hunger, satiety (both subj) |
No |
Sichieri et al. [41] |
203 women 25–45 years 23–30 kg/m2 |
18 months | LGI diet HGI diet Deficit 100–300 kcal/day |
↔ Weight loss | No |
Juanola-Falgarona et al. [24] | 122 overweight or obese adults 30–60 years 27–35 kg/m2 |
6 months | LGI HGI HGI-LFat 500 kcal energy restriction |
↔ Weight loss, WC ↔ BMI ↔ Hunger, satiety (both subj) |
No |
Karl et al. [42] |
46 overweight adults 20–42 years 25–29.9 kg/m2 |
12 months | LGL-10% energy restriction HGL-10% energy restriction LGL-30% energy restriction HGL-30% energy restriction |
↔ Weight loss | No |
Karl et al. [43] |
91 obese adults | 17 weeks | LGI-55% CHO HGI-55% CHO LGI-70% CHO HGI-70% CHO |
↔ Weight loss, body composition | No |
1 Abbreviations: BMI: body mass index; CHO: carbohydrate; GI: glycemic index; HGI: high GI; HGL: high glycemic load; LFat: low fat; LGI: low GI; LGL: low glycemic load; WC: waist circumference; ↓ lower; ↑: higher; ↔: no difference.