Skip to main content
. 2018 Jun 8;122(5):760–773. doi: 10.1111/bju.14368

Table 5.

COSMIN Checklist scores evaluating methodological quality of each study per measurement property and PROM

Measurement properties
Reference Content validity Structural validity Internal consistency Reliability Measurement error Hypothesis testing Criterion validity Responsiveness Cross‐cultural validity
Generic EQ‐5D
16 Fair
17 Fair
SF‐36
16 Fair
WHOQOL‐BREF
18 Poor
Cancer generic EORTC QLQ‐C30
19 Good Good
17 Fair
20 Fair
Bladder Cancer BCI
23 Fair
22 Excellent Good Good Fair Fair
16 Poor Poor Fair Fair Poor
24 Fair Fair
25 Poor Fair Fair Poor
21 Poor
FACT‐Bl
16 Fair
26 Poor
27 Poor Poor
28 Poor
MIBC FACT‐VCI
29 Good Good Fair Poor Fair
30 Poor Poor Fair Fair
31 Poor Poor Fair Poor
21 Poor
IONB‐PRO
32 Excellent Fair Fair Poor Fair
EORTC QLQ‐BLM30
17 Poor Fair
Untitled
36 Excellent Poor Poor
37 Poor
38 Excellent Poor
35 Excellent Poor Poor Poor
NMIBC EORTC QLQ‐NMIBC24
19 Poor Good Good
34 Fair Fair Fair
CAVICAVENMI
33 Excellent Good Poor Poor Fair