Skip to main content
. 2018 Sep 28;115(39):639–645. doi: 10.3238/arztebl.2018.0639

eTable 3. Study characteristics and results for the secondary endpoint walking ability.

Study Intervention Duration Frequency and time e n Severity (able to walk unaided) Risk of bias (generation of randomization sequence) Risk of bias (concealment of randomization sequence) Risk of bias (blinding of investigators) Months after stroke
Ada 2010 Treadmill training with body-weight support 4 weeks 30 min 3× per week 40 64 No Low Low Low 28.00
Ada 2010 Conventional walking rehabilitation 4 weeks 30 min 3× per week 48 62 No Low Low Low 26.00
Aschbacher 2006 Electromechanical-assisted walking training with exoskeleton 3 weeks 30 min 5× per week 0 11 Sometimes Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear
Aschbacher 2006 Conventional walking rehabilitation 3 weeks 30 min 5× per week 0 12 Sometimes Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear
Chang 2012 Electromechanical-assisted walking training with exoskeleton 1.5 weeks 100 min 5× per week 4 24 Sometimes Unclear Unclear High 0.53
Chang 2012 Conventional walking rehabilitation 1.5 weeks 100 min 5× per week 1 24 Sometimes Unclear Unclear High 0.59
da Cunha Filho 2002 Treadmill training with body-weight support 2 to 3 weeks 20 min 5× per week 3 6 No Low High High 0.52
da Cunha Filho 2002 Conventional walking rehabilitation 2 to 3 weeks 20 min 5× per week 3 7 No Low High High 0.62
Duncan 2011 Treadmill training with body-weight support 12 to 16 weeks 90 min 3× per week 135 282 No Unclear Low High 4.00
Duncan 2011 Conventional walking rehabilitation 12 to 16 weeks 90 min 3× per week 61 126 No Unclear Low High 2.00
Fisher 2008 Electromechanical-assisted walking training with exoskeleton 24 units 3–5× per week 9 10 Sometimes Unclear Unclear Low Unclear
Fisher 2008 Conventional walking rehabilitation 24 units 3–5× per week 9 10 Sometimes Unclear Unclear Low Unclear
Franceschini 2009 Treadmill training with body-weight support 5 weeks 60 min 5× per week 0 52 No Low Unclear Low 0.56
Franceschini 2009 Conventional walking rehabilitation 5 weeks 60 min 5× per week 0 50 No Low Unclear Low 0.46
Husemann 2007 Electromechanical-assisted walking training with exoskeleton 4 weeks 30 min 5× per week 0 17 No Low Low Low 2.60
Husemann 2007 Conventional walking rehabilitation 4 weeks 30 min 5× per week 0 15 No Low Low Low 2.93
Kosak 2000 Treadmill training with body-weight support 2 to 3 weeks 45 min 5× per week 20 22 No Low Low High 1.28
Kosak 2000 Conventional walking rehabilitation 2 to 3 weeks 45 min 5× per week 28 34 No Low Low High 1.32
Kyung 2008 Electromechanical-assisted walking training with exoskeleton 4 weeks 45 min 3× per week 12 18 Sometimes Unclear Unclear Unclear 22.00
Kyung 2008 Conventional walking rehabilitation 4 weeks 45 min 3× per week 7 17 Sometimes Unclear Unclear Unclear 29.00
Mayr 2008 Electromechanical-assisted walking training with exoskeleton 8 weeks 45 min 5× per week 9 37 Sometimes Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear
Mayr 2008 Conventional walking rehabilitation 8 weeks 45 min 5× per week 7 37 Sometimes Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear
Morone 2011 Electromechanical-assisted walking training with end-effector 4 weeks 40 min 5× per week 19 24 No Low Low Low 0.62
Morone 2011 Conventional walking rehabilitation 4 weeks 40 min 5× per week 10 24 No Low Low Low 0.66
Nilsson 2001a Treadmill training with body-weight support 9 to 10 weeks 30 min 5× per week 4 24 No Low Low Low 0.72
Nilsson 2001a Conventional walking rehabilitation 9 to 10 weeks 30 min 5× per week 4 25 No Low Low Low 0.56
Peurala 2005 Electromechanical-assisted walking training with end-effector 3 weeks 20 min 5× per week 14 30 Sometimes Low Low High 30.00
Peurala 2005 Conventional walking rehabilitation 3 weeks 20 min 5× per week 9 15 Sometimes Low Low High 48.00
Peurala 2009 Electromechanical-assisted walking training with end-effector 3 weeks 55 min 3× per week 5 22 Sometimes Low Low High 0.26
Peurala 2009 Conventional walking rehabilitation 3 weeks 55 min 3× per week 5 34 Sometimes Low Low High 0.26
Pohl 2007 Electromechanical-assisted walking training with end-effector 4 weeks 20 min 5× per week 41 77 No Low Low Low 0.97
Pohl 2007 Conventional walking rehabilitation 4 weeks 20 min 5× per week 17 78 No Low Low Low 1.04
Saltuari 2004 Electromechanical-assisted walking training with exoskeleton 2 weeks ABA study; in phase A 30 min 5× per week 1 8 Sometimes Low Unclear Unclear 3.60
Saltuari 2004 Conventional walking rehabilitation 2 weeks ABA study; in phase A 30 min 5× per week 1 8 Sometimes Low Unclear Unclear 1.90
Scheidtmann 1999 Treadmill training with body-weight support 3 weeks 60 min 5× per week 10 15 No Unclear Unclear Unclear 1.71
Scheidtmann 1999 Conventional walking rehabilitation 3 weeks 60 min 5× per week 11 15 No Unclear Unclear Unclear 1.71
Schwartz 2006 Electromechanical-assisted walking training with exoskeleton 6 weeks 3× per week 20 37 Sometimes Unclear Unclear High 0.72
Schwartz 2006 Conventional walking rehabilitation 6 weeks 3× per week 8 30 Sometimes Unclear Unclear High 0.79
Tong 2006 Electromechanical-assisted walking training with end-effector 4 weeks 20 min 5× per week 12 33 No Low Low Low 0.58
Tong 2006 Conventional walking rehabilitation 4 weeks 20 min 5× per week 6 21 No Low Low Low 0.62
Van Nunen 2012 Electromechanical-assisted walking training with exoskeleton 8 weeks 30 min 2× per week 12 16 Sometimes Unclear Low High 2.10
Van Nunen 2012 Conventional walking rehabilitation 8 weeks 60 min 1× per week 8 14 Sometimes Unclear Low High 2.10
Werner 2002a Treadmill training with body-weight support 2 weeks 15 to 20 min 5× per week 13 15 No Low Low Unclear 1.70
Werner 2002a Electromechanical-assisted walking training with end-effector 2 weeks 20 min 5× per week 10 15 No Low Low Unclear 1.59

ABA, A-B-A study design (A = baseline phase, B = intervention phase); SD, standard deviation