Skip to main content
. 2018 Oct 27;8(10):e021734. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-021734

Table 3.

Methodological quality of included articles

Test Study Country Population (age, diagnosis) Internal consistency Reliability Measurement error Content validity Structural validity Hypothesis testing Cross-cultural validity Criterion validity Responsiveness
Bayley-III Bayley31 USA 1–42 months Fair Fair Good Excellent Good Good Good
Spittle et al 4 Australia 2, 4 years, Ex prem Good
Visser et al 35 The Netherlands 2.2–10.8 years, GDD, LI Excellent Poor
BOT-2 Wuang and Su36 Taiwan 4–12 years ID Excellent Excellent Excellent Fair
Wuang et al 21 Taiwan 3–6 years ID Fair Good Good Good Fair
Bruininks and Bruininks12 USA 4–21 years Good Fair (inter-rater)
Fair (test–retest)
Good Excellent Good Good
MABC-2 (AB 1) Ellinoudis et al 37 Greece 3–5.5 years Excellent Good
Hua et al 19 China 3–6 years Excellent Good Excellent Excellent Poor Excellent
Logan et al 5 USA 3–6 years Fair Fair
Smits-Engelsman et al 28 Belgium 3–4 years Poor Poor Poor
MABC-2 (AB 2) Holm et al 23 Norway 7–9 years Fair (inter-rater)
Poor (intrarater)
Poor
Kita et al 38 Japan 7–10 years Excellent Poor
MABC-2 Griffiths et al 39 Australia 4–8 years Good
Henderson et al 29 UK 3–16 years Fair Good Excellent
Niemeijer et al 20 The Netherlands+
Belgium
Poor
Schulz et al 40 UK 3–16 years Excellent Good
Valentini et al 41 Brazil 3–13 years Fair Fair Fair Poor Poor Poor
Wuang et al 21 Taiwan 3–6 years, ID Fair Good Good Good Fair
Wuang et al 42 Taiwan 6–12 years DCD Poor Fair Good Fair
MAND Hands et al 43 Australia 10–17 years Excellent
McCarron32 USA 7 years Fair Poor Poor
NSMDA Danks et al 44 Australia 2+4 years ELBW Fair
MacDonald and Burns45 Australia 2+4 years CP Fair Poor
Burns et al 46 Australia 1–24 months VLBW Poor Poor
Burns et al 47 Australia 1 month VLBW Poor Fair
PDMS-2 Hua et al 19 China 3–6 years. Excellent Good Excellent Excellent Poor Excellent
Wuang et al 21 Taiwan 3–6 years ID Fair Good Good Good Fair
Folio and Fewell34 USA 0–71 months Good Poor Excellent Good Good Poor
TGMD-2 Barnett et al 24 Australia 4–8 years Fair
Farrokhi et al 48 Iran 3–11 years Fair Fair Fair Fair
Houwen et al 16 The Netherlands 6–12 years VI Fair Fair Fair
Kim et al 49 Korea 8–12 years ID Poor
Kim et al 50 Korea 5–6 years Poor Fair Poor Poor
Logan et al 5 USA 3–6 years Fair Fair
Rudd et al 13 Australia 6–12 years Good
Simons et al 18 Belgium 7–10 years ID Good Good (inter-rater)
Poor (test–retest)
Excellent Good Good
Valentini14 Brazil 3–10 years Poor Fair (test–retest)
Good (intrarater, inter-rater)
Excellent Good Fair Good
Wong and Yin Cheung17 China 3–10 years Fair
Ulrich15 USA 3–10 years Good Fair (test–retest)
Poor (inter-rater)
Fair Poor Good Fair

Bayley-III, Bayley Scale of Infant and Toddler Development third edition; BOT-2, Bruininks-Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency second edition12; CP, cerebral palsy; DCD, developmental coordination disorder; ELBW, extremely low birth weight; GDD, global developmental delay; ID, intellectual disability; LI, language impairment; MABC-2, Movement Assessment Battery for Children second edition29; MAND, McCarron Assessment of Neuromuscular Development32; NSMDA, Neurological Sensory Motor Developmental Assessment33; PDMS-2, Peabody Developmental Motor Scales second edition15 34; prem, premature; TGMD-II, Test of Gross Motor Development 2nd edition; VI, vision impairment; VLBW, very low birth weight.31