Table.
Strength of Evidence for Each Respiratory Symptom, Obstructive Lung Disease, Pulmonary Function, and Other Respiratory Outcomes
Outcome | Study Type | Strength of Evidence |
Comments |
---|---|---|---|
Respiratory symptoms | |||
Cough | 4 prospective observational studies (2 low* and 2 moderate ROB) and 7 cross-sectional studies (3 low, 3 moderate, and 1 high ROB) | Low | All prospective studies rated as low or moderate ROB and the pooled cross-sectional studies found an association between marijuana use and cough. |
Sputum production | 4 prospective observational studies (2 low* and 2 moderate ROB) and 5 cross-sectional studies (2 low, 2 moderate, and 1 high ROB) | Low | Low- and moderate-ROB studies showed a consistent trend toward increased risk for sputum production with marijuana use. Pooled data showed that marijuana use was associated with an increased risk for sputum production. |
Wheezing | 4 prospective observational studies (2 low* and 2 moderate ROB) and 7 cross-sectional studies (3 low, 3 moderate, and 1 high ROB) | Low | Three prospective studies (1 low and 2 moderate ROB) showed that marijuana use was associated with increased risk for wheezing. Pooled analysis of 4 cross-sectional studies (1 low and 3 moderate ROB) showed that marijuana use was associated with wheezing, but heterogeneity was high. Low- and moderate-ROB studies showed a consistent trend toward an association between marijuana use and wheezing. |
Dyspnea | 2 prospective observational studies*(low ROB) and 5 cross-sectional studies (2 low, 2 moderate, and 1 high ROB) | Insufficient | The prospective studies were based on the same cohort, and the study with the longest follow-up found no effect on increased risk for dyspnea. This study was limited because the median marijuana exposure was not reported; however, the pooled analysis from cross-sectional studies showed that marijuana use was associated with increased risk for dyspnea. |
Obstructive lung disease | 1 prospective observational cohort study (moderate ROB) and 5 cross-sectional studies (2 low, 2 moderate, and 1 high ROB) | Insufficient | One prospective study found an increased risk for chronic bronchitis during a long follow-up. Pooled analysis of 3 cross-sectional studies (1 low and 2 moderate ROB) did not show that marijuana use was associated with increased risk for chronic bronchitis. All studies showed a trend toward increased risk for chronic bronchitis from marijuana use; however, the body of available evidence was limited. |
Pulmonary function | |||
FEV1 | 4 prospective observational cohort studies (3 low and 1 moderate ROB) and 6 cross-sectional studies (3 low, 2 moderate, and 1 high ROB) | Insufficient | The low-ROB prospective studies found no effect on decrease of FEV1; however, the studies were limited by minimal exposure to marijuana and the young age of participants. The cross-sectional studies were limited by small sample size, a young population, and variable rigor in analysis; the experimental study was limited by lack of adjustment for key confounders. |
FVC | 2 prospective observational cohort studies (low ROB) and 4 cross-sectional studies (3 low and 1 high ROB) | Insufficient | The prospective studies showed mixed results with marijuana use and an increase in FVC, and the 2 cross-sectional studies showed no effect of marijuana on FVC, but study quality and rigor in analysis varied. |
FEV1-FVC ratio | 4 prospective observational cohort studies (2 low* and 2 moderate ROB) and 6 cross-sectional studies (3 low and 3 moderate ROB) | Insufficient | All low-ROB prospective studies were based on the same cohort study. The studies with the longest follow-up did not report average marijuana exposure in the cohort. The cross-sectional studies were limited by few marijuana-only smokers, variable rigor in analysis, and mixed findings. |
Airway resistance and specific conductance of airways | 1 prospective cohort study (low ROB) and 3 cross-sectional studies (1 low, 1 moderate, and 1 high ROB) | Low | All relevant studies found that marijuana use was associated with increased airway resistance and decreased specific conductance of airways. |
Other respiratory outcomes | 2 prospective observational studies (1 low and 1 high ROB) and 2 cross-sectional studies (low ROB) | Insufficient | The prospective studies were limited by inadequate marijuana exposure, inadequate adjustment for confounders, and many other methodological flaws with mixed findings. |
ROB = risk of bias.
Both studies were based on the same cohort.