Table 1. Recommendations for when to consider that a patient’s illness is treatment resistant used in international guidelines.
Guideline | Requirements of previous treatment | Severity of illness | Other | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Minimum number of failed APs | Specified AP | Adequate treatment episode duration | Dose | |||
APA(6) | 2 | “At least one of which is a second-generation AP” | ≥6 weeks | Therapeutic range | “a clinically inadequate response” “and for patients with persistent suicidal ideation or behaviour that has not responded to other treatments” | Nil |
RANZCP (90) | 2 | Recommends both first and second trial to be of an atypical | 6-8 weeks | Dosages specified for | “Poor response” | “If poor… adherence, or persistent suicide risk, positively offer trial of clozapine.” |
BAP(91) | 2 | “One of the trials should be of an antipsychotic with an established, favourable, efficacy profile in comparison with other antipsychotics” | ‘Adequate’ | ‘Adequate’ | ‘schizophrenic illness has shown a poor response to, or intolerance of the neurological side effects of [previous treatment]’ | “Poor…adherence and …substance use should be excluded as causes of the …poor response to AP “ |
IPAP(92) | 2 | “…a typical or, if not available a trial of haloperidol, chlorpromazine or other typical antipsychotic” | 4-6 weeks | ‘Adequate’ | Psychosis or mod-to-severe TD or tardive dystonia after adjusting dose” | Nil |
Maudsley (79) | 2 | Consider use of either first generation or second generation AP | 2-3 weeks for trial of first AP in FEP. 6 week trial for subsequent 2nd AP before clozapine. | At least minimum effective dose, then titrated to response | Not specified | Nil |
MOHS(93) | 2 | No | Adequate | Adequate | “illness has not responded adequately to treatment” | 2 trials should be given “sequentially” |
NICE(5) | 2 | “One of the drugs should be a non-clozapine second-generation AP” | Not specified | Adequate | “illness has not responded adequately to treatment” | 2 trials should be given “sequentially” |
WFSBP(7) | 2 | “one of which should be an atypical antipsychotic” | 6-8 weeks | Recommended dosage | no improvement at all or only insufficient improvement in the target symptoms | Compliance should be ensured, if necessary by checking drug concentrations |
AP – Antipsychotic; APA – American Psychiatric Assocation; BAP – British Association for Psychopharmacology; FEP – First Episode Psychosis; IPAP - The International Psychopharmacology Algorithm Project; MOHS – Ministry of Health Singapore; NICE – National Institute for Clinical Excellence; RANZCP - Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists; WFSBP - World Federation of Societies of Biological Psychiatry.