Skip to main content
. 2018 Nov 5;8(11):e021070. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-021070

Table 2.

Meta-analysis of outcomes and level of evidence

Variable Overall effect Studies (N) Sample size (N) Level of evidence
MD 95% CI P values I2 P values Statistical method
Cupping versus waitlist (sole)
 Pain (VAS) −2.42 −3.98 to –0.86 0.002 93 <0.00001 Random inverse variance 5 241 Very low
 Pain (VAS) omitting one study −1.48 −1.86 to –1.10 <0.00001 0 0.57 Random inverse variance 4 181
 Disability (NDI) −4.34 −6.77 to –1.91 0.0005 6 0.35 Random inverse variance 3 141 Low
 QoL
 (physical component of SF-36)
2.46 −0.36 to 5.29 0.09 24 0.27 Random inverse variance 3 141 Low
 QoL
 (mental component of SF-36)
5.32 0.83 to 9.80 0.02 32 0.23 Random inverse variance 3 141 Low
Cupping versus active control (sole)
 Pain (VAS) −0.89 −1.42 to –0.37 0.0009 88 <0.00001 Random inverse variance 9 870 Low
 Pain (VAS) of dry cupping −1.48 −1.86 to –1.10 <0.00001 0 0.57 Random inverse variance 3 149
 Pain (VAS) of wet cupping −0.70 −1.32 to –0.07 0.03 92 <0.00001 Random inverse variance 6 721
 Pain (VAS) of wet cupping omitting one study −0.49 −0.78 to –0.20 0.0008 35 0.19 Random inverse variance 5 521
 Disability (NDI) −4.36 −8.67 to –0.04 0.05 62 0.05 Random inverse variance 4 213 Very low
 QoL (SF-36)
 (physical component of SF-36)
5.44 2.09 to 8.78 0.001 7 0.30 Random inverse variance 2 109 Low
 QoL (SF-36)
 (mental component of SF-36)
0.44 −4.05 to 4.93 0.85 0 0.59 Random inverse variance 2 109 Low
Cupping with active control versus control (add-on)
 Pain (VAS) −0.87 −1.14 to –0.61 <0.00001 19 0.29 Random inverse variance 5 534 Low
 Disability (NDI) 3.61 −3.93 to 11.15 0.35 Random inverse variance 1 56 Low

MD, mean difference; NDI, Neck Disability Index; QoL, quality of life; SF-36, 36-Item Short Form Health Survey; VAS, visual analogue scale.