Table 3.
Overview of the included studies.
Study | Measurement of eHealth Literacy (Validity or Reliability) | HIV-Related Health Outcome | Main Findings |
Blackstock et al, 2016 [28] | eHEALSa Dichotomized at the median (high vs low health literacy; alpha=.88) | HIV transmission risk behaviors, including condomless vaginal or anal intercourse, and any illicit drug use in the previous 30 days | Higher eHealth literacy, AORb 3.90 (95% CI 1.05-14.56), significantly associated with HIV transmission risk behaviors, adjusted for income and self-perceived health status. |
Kim et al, 2015 [29] | Study questions: “Are you able to read?” and “Are you able to write?” (validity or reliability not reported) | Viral suppression (CD4c count), adherence to ARTd | Literate mobile phone users had lower adherence to ART (84.2% vs 90.6%; P=.007) and more favorable perception of utilizing reminders to support the adherence to treatment (57.1% vs 36.7%; P<.001) than those who were either illiterate, did not have a mobile phone, or both. There was no difference between literate mobile users and other study participants in the virological suppression. |
Krishnan et al, 2015 [30] | Short Test of Functional Health Literacy in Adults (validity or reliability not reported) | ART adherence | No significant differences were found in communication technology use and mHealth acceptance among participants with alcohol use disorders, depression, and suboptimal ART adherence. |
Ownby et al, 2012 [26] | TOFHLAe<59, inadequate; 60-74, marginal; >75, adequate (validity or reliability not reported) | Medication adherence | Changes in the adherence only approached the statistical significance. Knowledge and behavioral skills increased over the course of the study. |
Robinson et al, 2010 [27] | eHEALS (validity or reliability not reported) | HIV-related health outcome not measured | A significant improvement from the baseline to immediately following the intervention was observed in perceived eHealth literacy levels (mean summary score 19 vs 32, P<.01) and perceptions of ability to use the internet (P<.05). |
Siedner et al, 2015 [24] | Participants were asked to read a complete sentence in the local language (validity or reliability not reported) | Retention in care defined as a return to the clinic within 7 days of the first SMSf text message for those with abnormal results or on the date of the scheduled appointment for those with normal results | The ability to read a complete sentence on enrollment was independently associated with accurate identification of the message sent, AOR 4.54 (95% CI 1.42-14.47), and return to the clinic within 7 d of the first transmitted SMS text message, AOR 3.81 (95% CI 1.61-9.03). An ability to access an SMS text message on enrollment was independently associated with returning to the clinic within 7 days of an abnormal SMS text notification, AOR 4.90 (95% CI 1.06-22.61). |
Woods et al, 2016 [25] | TOPSg; TOHRNh; eHEALS; Rapid Estimate of Adult Literacy in Medicine; HIV Knowledge 18; Expanded Numeracy Scale; TOFHLA; Short Assessment of Health Literacy; Newest Vital Sign (validity or reliability not reported) | CD4 count and HIV plasma viral load | Lower TOPS scores were associated with fewer years of education (ρ=.49, P=.003), higher HIV viral load (correlation=−.47, P=.006), less frequent computer and internet use (P<.05) and not owning a smartphone (P<.05); lower TOHRN scores were associated with lower education (ρ=.40, P=.01), higher HIV viral load (ρ=–.032, P=.045), less frequent internet use (P<.05), and anxiety related to computer use (P<.05). |
aeHEALS: eHealth Literacy Scale.
bAOR: adjusted odds ratio.
cCD4: cluster of differentiation 4.
dART: antiretroviral therapy.
eTOFHLA: Test of Functional Health Literacy in Adults.
fSMS: short message service.
gTOPS: Test of Online Pharmacy Skills.
hTOHRN: Test of Online Health Records Navigation.