Skip to main content
. 2018 Oct 15;8:442. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2018.00442

Table 1.

Basic information about the 45 studies that met the inclusion criteria for this systematic review.

References Tumor type Tumor site Number of samples Sample Species
Stasikowska-Kanicka et al. (20) SCC Oral cavity (floor of the mouth) 78 Patients (41 poor prognosis, 37 better prognosis)
18 Controls (normal mucosa)
Tumor Human
Hussaini et al. (31) SCC Oral cavity 25 Patients
12 Controls (inflammatory hyperplastic tissue)
Tumor Human
Ihara et al. (17) SCC Oral cavity, oropharynx, nasopharynx, larynx, maxillary sinus 46 SCC 23 Controls Blood Human
Ma et al. (32) SCC HNC Human samples: 43 Normal 48 Dysplastic
165 Primary HNSCC
12 Recurrent HNSCC
17 HNSCC with induction chemotherapy Murine samples: 6 WT normal tongue
6 WT tumor bearing mice
6 KO tumor bearing mice
Tumor Human/Murine
Zhou et al. (33) SCC Tongue 46 SCC
46 Paired tumor adjacent non-neoplastic tongue epithelium
20 Metastasis lymph nodes
20 Paired normal cervical lymph nodes
Tumor Human
Nguyen et al. (25) SCC Larynx, oral cavity, oropharynx, hypopharynx 278 SCC Tumor Human
Miki et al. (34) SCC Tongue 20 Controls
20 4NQO
40 4NQO treated with COX-2 inhibitor
Tumor Murine
da Cunha Filho et al. (35) SCC Low lip 50 Patients,
10 microscopic fields per patient
Tumor Human
Montler et al. (36) SCC Base of the tongue, tonsil, oropharynx, nasal, oral tongue, mandibular gingiva, maxillary sinus, larynx, floor of the mouth 29 Patients Tumor blood Human
Takahashi et al. (37) SCC Oral cavity, oropharynx, hypopharynx, larynx, paranasal cavity 20 Healthy controls
44 Patients treated with surgery/radio/radio-chemotherapy 16 Chemotherapy
Blood Human
Jie et al. (18) SCC Oral cavity, oropharynx, larynx, hypopharynx 22 Patients treated with cetuximab plus cisplatin/paclitaxel/radiotherapy followed by
6 months of maintenance single agent cetuximab
18 Patients received single-agent cetuximab
Tumor blood Human
Partlova et al. (38) SCC Tongue, tonsil, larynx, verbal base, hypopharynx, Gl. submandibularis, floor of mouth 54 Patients Tumor blood Human
Wolf et al. (29) SCC Oral cavity: tongue, upper alveolus, floor of mouth, hard palate, buccal mucosa, and retromolar 39 Patients Blood Human
Sun et al. (39) SCC Oral cavity, hypopharynx, nasopharynx, oropharynx, larynx 112 Patients
31 Healthy donors
Blood Human
Schipmann et al. (40) SCC Oral cavity and skin FOXP3 mRNA expression: 13 Cutaneous cSCC
8 Oral SCC
14 SCC metastases Immunohistochemistry: 10 Cutaneous SCC
8 Oral SCC
4 SCC metastases
10 Normal skin control Cell lines: Primary human adult skin fibroblasts Human squamous cell carcinoma cell line
Tumor Human
Lim et al. (23) SCC Oral cavity 39 Patients 24 Controls Blood Human
Hanakawa et al. (16) SCC Tongue 34 Patients Tumor Human
Ward et al. (28) SCC Oropharynx 149 HPV+ 121 HPV– Tumor Human
Lukesova et al. (24) SCC Oral cavity, oropharynx 60 Patients Blood Human
Zhao et al. (41) SCC Tongue 16 Controls 32 4NQO Tumor blood Rat
Jie et al. (42) SCC Oral cavity, oropharynx 27 Patients Tumor blood Human
Park et al. (26) SCC Tonsil 79 Patients Tumor Human
Weed et al. (43) SCC Tongue 49 Patients Tumor Human
Drennan et al. (44) SCC Oropharynx, larynx 14 Controls 39 Patients Blood Human
Bron et al. (22) SCC Oral cavity, oropharynx, hypopharynx, larynx 35 Patients Tumor blood Human
Judd et al. (19) SCC Oral cancer cell line injected in flank Not disclosed in manuscript Tumor Murine
Gaur et al. (45) SCC Oral cavity 45 Patients 40 Controls Blood Human
Wansom et al. (27) SCC Oropharynx 46 Patients Tumor blood Human
Wild et al. (46) SCC Oral cavity, pharynx, larynx 35 Patients 17 Controls Tumor blood Human
Näsman et al. (47) SCC Tonsil 31 HPV+ with a good clinical outcome
21 HPV+ with a poor clinical outcome 11 HPV– with a good clinical outcome
20 HPV– with a poor clinical outcome
Tumor Human
Lee et al. (48) SCC Oral cavity 38 Patients 5 Controls Tumor blood Human
Schuler et al. (49) SSC Oral cavity, pharynx, larynx 9 Patient samples for dendritic cell culture
13 Patient samples for Treg frequency
Blood Human
Alhamarneh et al. (50) SCC Larynx, oropharynx, oral cavity, hypopharynx, nasal cavity, lymph node metastasis, unknown primary site 107 Patients pretreatment
43 4–6 weeks posttreatment
40 Controls
Blood Human
Al-Qahtani et al. (51) SCC Oral cavity 34 Patients Tumor Human
Tominaga et al. (52) MM Oral cavity 7 Patients
10 Controls
Tumor Blood Canine
Horiuchi et al. (53) MM Oral cavity 15 Patients
10 Controls
Blood Canine
Schott et al. (54) SCC Epipharynx, oropharynx, hypopharynx, larynx, oral cavity 16 Patients with active disease
16 Patients with no evidence of disease 21 Controls
Blood Human
Gasparoto et al. (55) SCC Oral cavity, lip 9 Patients
10 Controls
Tumor Blood Human
Boucek et al. (15) SCC Oral cavity, hypopharynx, larynx 112 Patients
20 Controls
Blood Human
Distel et al. (56) SCC Oral cavity, hypopharynx, oropharynx 62 Low-risk group patients with early disease 53 High-risk group inoperable patients with advanced disease Tumor Human
Schwarz et al. (57) SCC Oral cavity 15 Patients
15 Controls
Tumor Human
Bergmann et al. (58) SCC HNSCC cell lines from primary tumors Cell culture of irradiated HNSCC cell lines from primary tumors with blood samples from 10 healthy donors Blood Human
Chikamatsu et al. (59) SCC Oral cavity, oropharynx, hypopharynx, larynx, paranasal sinuses 43 Patients
24 Controls
Blood Human
Badoual et al. (21) SCC Oral cavity, oropharynx, hypopharynx 84 Patients Tumor Human
Schaefer et al. (60) SCC Larynx, oral cavity, pharynx, hypopharynx 24 Patients
17 Controls
Blood Human

SCC, Squamous Cell Carcinoma; MM, Multiple Myeloma; HNC, Head and Neck Cancer; HNSCC, Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma.