Skip to main content
. 2019 Jan 15;648:80–89. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2018.08.122

Table 1.

Comparison of model performance for the prediction of BCF in Cyprinus carpio. MAE is the mean absolute error and NA indicates the metric was not applicable.

Model RMSE
R2
MAE
Training Verification Test Training Verification Test Training Verification Test
Trajan Linear 0.785 1.052 0.832 0.532 0.390 0.521 0.619 0.835 0.608
GRNN 0.830 0.893 0.873 0.673 0.400 0.569 0.664 0.893 0.718
RBF 0.723 0.689 0.584 0.651 0.635 0.725 0.565 1.600 0.450
3-MLP 0.689 0.538 0.337 0.675 0.770 0.659 0.548 1.608 0.553
4-MLP 0.403 0.524 0.644 0.887 0.819 0.702 0.313 0.380 0.530
Model Training Cross-Validation Test Training Cross-Validation Test Training Cross-Validation Test
R OLM 0.719 0.771 1.203 0.621 0.570 0.234 0.560 NA 0.778
PLS 0.722 0.769 1.164 0.618 0.571 0.254 0.564 NA 0.765
RR 0.725 0.766 1.083 0.614 0.576 0.304 0.568 NA 0.753
EN 0.729 0.760 1.054 0.612 0.582 0.314 0.577 NA 0.754
QRL 0.733 0.757 1.112 0.607 0.585 0.284 0.562 NA 0.770
KNN 0.517 0.683 0.902 0.807 0.665 0.468 0.404 NA 0.648
ELM 0.673 0.756 1.014 0.668 0.593 0.346 0.529 NA 0.768
ANN-1HL 0.596 0.751 0.877 0.739 0.597 0.505 0.462 NA 0.620
ANN-a1HL 0.395 0.672 0.859 0.888 0.678 0.518 0.319 NA 0.612
ANN-2HL 0.232 0.834 1.022 0.962 0.560 0.370 0.174 NA 0.680
ANN-3HL 0.454 0.795 0.880 0.860 0.582 0.520 0.345 NA 0.624
MARS 0.539 0.730 1.014 0.787 0.632 0.390 0.425 NA 0.696
B-MARS 0.500 0.681 0.899 0.819 0.673 0.479 0.395 NA 0.633
SVM-R 0.383 0.644 0.841 0.893 0.704 0.537 0.261 NA 0.590
SVM-P 0.699 0.747 1.029 0.643 0.594 0.340 0.539 NA 0.729
RF-CART 0.292 0.675 0.771 0.956 0.688 0.633 0.231 NA 0.589
RF-CIT 0.605 0.739 0.821 0.762 0.630 0.586 0.485 NA 0.652
BT 0.249 0.660 0.789 0.957 0.687 0.593 0.187 NA 0.587
CR 0.353 0.678 0.973 0.910 0.673 0.431 0.282 NA 0.628