Skip to main content
. 2018 Oct 30;6(1):e000534. doi: 10.1136/bmjdrc-2018-000534

Table 1.

Quality assessment results for the included studies

Authors (year) Selection bias Study design Confounders Blinding Data collection methods Withdrawal and dropouts Global rating
Wright et al 44 (2017) Moderate Strong Weak Moderate Strong Moderate Moderate
Lee et al 45 (2016) Strong Strong Strong Moderate Strong Strong Strong
Bunner et al 41 (2015) Strong Strong Strong Moderate Strong Strong Strong
Soare et al 43 (2014) Strong Strong Strong Moderate Strong Strong Strong
Mishra et al 39 (2013) Moderate Strong Strong Moderate Strong Moderate Strong
Kahleova et al 35 (2013) Strong Strong Strong Moderate Strong Strong Strong
Kahleova et al 36 (2011) Strong Strong Strong Moderate Strong Strong Strong
Ferdowsian et al 40 (2010) Moderate Strong Strong Moderate Strong Strong Strong
Barnard et al 37 (2009b) Strong Strong Strong Moderate Strong Strong Strong
Barnard et al 38 (2009a) Strong Strong Strong Moderate Strong Strong Strong
Nicholson et al 42 (1999) Strong Strong Strong Moderate Strong Moderate Strong