Table 7.
Parameters | Biostimulant treatment | Biostimulant | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Atonik | Tytanit | ||||||||
Season | Average | Season | Average | ||||||
2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | ||||
NDF (% DM) | C | 20.34e | 20.40e | 20.28c | 20.34b | 20.34e | 20.40e | 20.28d | 20.34c |
LSS | 12.85a | 9.57a | 12.91a | 11.78a | 16.69b | 19.00d | 16.65b | 17.45ab | |
LDS | 12.96b | 16.26c | 13.00a | 14.07a | 19.34c | 17.60b | 19.29c | 18.74bc | |
HSS | 17.23c | 20.16s | 17.78b | 18.39b | 20.04d | 17.21a | 20.71e | 19.32c | |
HDS | 19.80d | 13.16b | 20.30c | 17.75b | 15.46a | 18.69c | 15.10a | 16.41a | |
Average | 16.64b | 15.91a | 16.85c | 18.37a | 18.58b | 18.58a | |||
ADF (% DM) | C | 15.51b | 14.54b | 15.47b | 15.17a | 15.51a | 14.54a | 15.47a | 15.17a |
LSS | 16.23d | 12.96a | 16.45d | 15.21a | 16.25b | 20.05b | 16.86c | 17.72a | |
LDS | 15.99c | 18.46e | 15.94c | 16.80b | 15.47a | 19.24b | 16.07b | 16.93a | |
HSS | 14.62a | 15.84c | 15.06a | 15.17a | 15.36a | 19.72b | 15.85b | 16.98a | |
HDS | 17.91e | 16.64d | 17.54e | 17.36b | 16.24b | 18.76b | 16.58c | 17.19a | |
Average | 16.05b | 15.69a | 16.09c | 15.77a | 18.46b | 16.174a | |||
ADL (% DM) | C | 4.89b | 6.07a | 4.91b | 5.29ab | 4.89a | 6.07a | 4.91a | 5.29a |
LSS | 7.01e | 6.26b | 6.92e | 6.73ab | 7.15e | 9.35b | 7.11b | 7.87a | |
LDS | 5.20c | 10.60e | 5.57c | 7.12b | 5.02b | 11.61e | 4.89a | 7.17a | |
HSS | 4.33a | 6.64c | 4.32a | 5.10a | 5.18c | 10.00c | 5.14ab | 6.77a | |
HDS | 5.96d | 8.06d | 5.81d | 6.61ab | 6.32d | 10.51d | 6.52ab | 7.78a | |
Average | 5.48a | 7.53c | 5.51b | 5.71a | 9.51b | 5.71a | |||
HCEL (% DM) | C | 4.83d | 5.86c | 4.81c | 5.17d | 4.83d | 5.86c | 4.81c | 5.17c |
LSS | 0.00a | 0.00a | 0.00a | 0.00a | 0.44b | 0.00a | 0.00a | 0.15a | |
LDS | 0.00a | 0.00a | 0.00a | 0.00a | 3.87c | 0.95a | 3.22b | 2.68b | |
HSS | 2.61c | 4.32b | 2.72b | 3.21c | 4.68d | 0.00a | 4.86b | 3.18b | |
HDS | 1.89b | 0.00a | 2.76b | 1.55b | 0.00a | 0.00a | 0.00a | 0.00a | |
Average | 1.87a | 1.04b | 2.06b | 2.76b | 1.36a | 2.58b | |||
CE (% DM) | C | 10.52c | 8.47c | 10.56c | 9.85ab | 10.52d | 8.47a | 10.56a | 9.85a |
LSS | 9.22a | 6.70a | 9.53a | 8.48a | 9.10a | 10.70a | 9.75a | 9.85a | |
LDS | 10.29b | 7.86b | 10.37b | 9.67ab | 10.45d | 7.63a | 11.18a | 9.75a | |
HSS | 10.79d | 9.20d | 10.74d | 10.08ab | 10.18c | 9.72a | 10.71a | 10.20a | |
HDS | 11.95e | 8.58c | 11.73e | 10.75b | 9.92b | 8.25a | 10.06a | 9.41a | |
Average | 10.55b | 8.16a | 10.58b | 10.03a | 8.95a | 10.45a |
C, control; LSS, lower concentration single spraying; LDS, lower concentration double spraying; HSS, higher concentration single spraying; HDS, higher concentration double spraying. Means in the columns, concerning the selected traits, followed by different small letters are significantly different at p < 0.05.