Table 6.
The characteristics of mixed-methods research in mHealth-based diabetes management studies examined in this review (part 1).
| Author, year | Main purpose of the study | Recognition of MMa | Purpose of mixing | Formal MM research question | Prioritized method | Stage of integration | Design type |
| Allen et al, 2009 [33] | To assess feasibility and acceptability of continuous glucose monitoring and accelerometer technology in exercising type 2 diabetic patients | Yes, as multimethod | Complementarity | No | Equal | Sampling and interpretation | Explanatory sequential |
| Baron et al, 2015 [34] | To identify the challenges related to recruitment, fidelity, implementation, and context of mobile telehealth interventions targeting diabetic patients | Yes | Complementarity: different measures for different parts of the research phenomenon | No | QUANb | Sampling, data collection, data analysis, and interpretation | Embedded |
| Baron et al, 2016 [35] | To examine the behavioral effects of a mobile phone–based home telehealth intervention in diabetic patients | No | Triangulation | No | QUAN | Sampling and interpretation | Embedded |
| Burner et al, 2013 [36] | To explore the attitudes of inner-city Latino patients toward TExT-MEDd program and other health information sources | Yes | Initiation: the qualitative study was conducted to understand the contradictory findings of the quantitative method | No | Equal | Sampling and interpretation | Explanatory sequential |
| Carroll et al, 2007 [37] | To evaluate user satisfaction with an mHealth diabetes monitoring system | Yes | Sequential development | No | QUAN | Discussion or interpretation | Exploratory sequential |
| Franklin et al, 2008 [38] | To explore the interactions of type 1 patients with SMS text messaging support | Yes | Triangulation | No | Equal | Sampling, data analysis, and interpretation | Concurrent |
| Froisland et al, 2012 [39] | To explore ways mobile apps can be used to monitor adolescents with type 1 diabetes | Yes | Triangulation | No | QUALc | Sampling, data collection, and interpretation | Embedded |
| Georgsson and Staggers, 2016 [40] | To test the feasibility of a multimethod approach for patients’ experienced usability of a diabetes mHealth system | Yes, as multimethod | Triangulation | No | Equal | Sampling, data analyses, and interpretation | Concurrent |
| Grindrod et al, 2014 [41] | To examine the usability and usefulness of mobile medication apps with older adults | Yes | Triangulation | No | Equal | Sampling, interpretation, and data analysis | Concurrent |
| Jones et al, 2015 [42] | To evaluate the attitudes of American Indian women toward postpartum intervention approaches (including mHealth) and risk factors for developing gestational diabetes | Yes | Complementarity: different measures for different parts of the research phenomenon | No | QUAL | Sampling and interpretation | Embedded |
| Nundy et al, 2014 [43] | To investigate the behavioral effects of a theory-driven mobile phone–based intervention using an automated, interactive SMS text messaging system | Yes | Triangulation | No | QUAN | Sampling and interpretation | Embedded design |
| Osborn and Mulvaney, 2013 [44] | To examine the capability of an SMS text messaging and interactive voice response intervention for low-income adults with type 2 diabetes mellitus | Yes | Sequential development | No | Equal | Sampling, data analysis, and interpretation | Embedded |
| Verwey et al, 2016 [45] | To examine the reach, implementation, and satisfaction with a counseling tool combining an accelerometer, a mobile phone, and a Web application | Yes | Triangulation | No | Equal | Sampling, interpretation, and data analysis | Embedded |
| van der Weegen et al, 2014 [46] | To test the usability of a monitoring and feedback tool targeting diabetic patients | Yes | Sequential development | No | Equal | Sampling, data collection, data analysis, and interpretation | Multiphase study |
aMM: mixed methods.
bQUAN: quantitative.
cQUAL: qualitative.
dTExT-MED: Trial to Examine Text Message–Based mHealth in Emergency Department Patients With Diabetes.