Skip to main content
. 2018 Nov 16;16:110. doi: 10.1186/s12961-018-0382-1

Table 1.

Methodological quality ratings of included studies

Included paper Study design Type of study Sampling Type of data Type of analysis Sa (%)
Adjorlolo, Abdul-Nasiru [32] Cross-sectional Quantitative Not reported Questionnaire Inferential statistics 90
Ae-Ngibise, Cooper [45] Not reported Qualitative Purposive IDIs and FGD Thematic analysis 75
Ae-Ngibise, Adiibokah [42] Longitudinal Mixed methods IDIs and review Not reported Thematic analysis 60
Agyapong, Farren [47] Cross-sectional Mixed methods Questionnaire Purposive Descriptive and inferential statistics 73
Agyapong, Osei [56] Cross-sectional Mixed methods Questionnaire Purposive Descriptive and inferential statistics 77
Agyapong, Osei [31] Cross-sectional Mixed methods Questionnaire Purposive Descriptive and inferential statistics 77
Agyapong, Osei [51] Cross-sectional Mixed methods Questionnaire and IDIs Purposive Descriptive statistics and Thematic content analysis 77
Agyapong, Osei [48] Cross-sectional Mixed methods Questionnaire Purposive Descriptive and inferential statistics 63.6
Akpalu, Lund [55] Cross-sectional Mixed methods IDIs and WHO Assessment Instrument Purposive Thematic analysis 73
Appiah-Poku, Laugharne [58] Not reported Quantitative Questionnaire Not reported Not reported 81
Arias, Taylor [59] Not reported Qualitative IDIs Purposive Constant comparative 75
Asamoah, Osafo [44] Not reported Qualitative IDIs Not reported Thematic analysis 75
Awenva, Read [30] Not reported Mixed methods IDIs, FGD and WHO Assessment Instrument Not reported Thematic analysis 73
Bhana, Petersen [46] Not reported Mixed methods IDIs, FGD and WHO Assessment Instrument Not reported Thematic analysis 73
Bird, Omar [29] Not reported Qualitative IDIs Purposive Thematic analysis 75
Canavan, Sipsma [49] Not reported Quantitative Document review Not reported Descriptive and inferential statistics 63.6
Cohen, Raja [43] Not reported Qualitative Participatory - Observations, field notes taking Not reported Not reported 87.5
de Menil, Osei [60] Cross-sectional Quantitative Questionnaire Random, stratified and purposive Descriptive and inferential statistics 100
Doku, Ofori-Atta [41] Not reported Qualitative IDIs and FGD Purposive Thematic analysis 100
Gyamfi, Hegadoren [61] Descriptive Qualitative In-depth interview Not reported Thematic analysis 75
Ibrahim, Hor [62] Cross-sectional Quantitative Questionnaire Purposive Descriptive and inferential statistics 90.9
Jack, Canavan [36] Not reported Qualitative IDIs Snowballing Constant comparative 75
Kleintjes, Lund [10] Not reported Mixed methods IDIs, FGD and WHO Assessment Instrument Purposive Thematic analysis 60
Kpobi and Swartz [63] Not reported Qualitative IDIs Snowballing Thematic analysis 62.5
Kpobi and Swartz [52] Not reported Qualitative IDIs Snowballing Thematic analysis 75
Kyei, Dueck [64] Not reported Mixed methods Questionnaire Random sample Descriptive and inferential statistics 63.6
Mfoafo-M’Carthy, Sottie [37] Not reported Qualitative Document review Not reported Thematic analysis 45
Ofori-Atta, Attafuah [53] RCT Quantitative Questionnaire Randomisation Descriptive and inferential statistics 100
Ofori-Atta, Attafuah [35] Not reported Mixed methods IDIs and WHO Assessment Instrument Purposive Thematic analysis 80
Opare-Henaku and Utsey [38] Not reported Qualitative IDIs Not reported Thematic analysis 100
Oppong, Kretchy [65] Not reported Qualitative IDIs Convenience Thematic analysis 100
Osafo [66] Not reported Qualitative Review Not reported Synthesis 20
Osafo, Agyapong [67] Not reported Qualitative IDIs Purposive and Snowballing Thematic analysis 75
Quinn [33] Not reported Qualitative IDIs Not reported Descriptive 75
Raja, Wood [50] Not reported Qualitative IDIs and document review Purposive Descriptive statistics and Thematic content analysis 100
Read [57] Ethnographic Qualitative IDIs, FGD and observation Purposive Grounded theory approach 75
Read, Adiibokah [54] Ethnographic Qualitative IDIs and FGD Not reported Not reported 100
Roberts, Mogan [40] Not reported Mixed methods WHO-AIMS tool and Questionnaire Purposive Thematic analysis 86.6
Salifu Yendork, Kpobi [39] Phenomenological Qualitative IDIs, FGD and observation Purposive, Snowballing and Convenience Interpretative Phenomenological analyses 100
Stefanovics, He [34] Exploratory Qualitative Questionnaire Convenience Descriptive and inferential statistics 72.7
Tawiah, Adongo [68] Cross-sectional Mixed methods IDIs and FGD Random sample Descriptive and inferential statistics 77
van der Watt, Nortje [69] Not reported Qualitative FGD Not reported Thematic analysis 100

FGD focus group discussion, IDI in-depth interview

aMethodological quality score