Table 1.
Pharmacological Trials | Medical Device Trials | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Phase I | Phase II | Phase III | Phase IV | Feasibility (preliminary or pilot) | Pivotal | |
Main goal | Safety | Safety, efficacy | Effectiveness, efficacy, safety | Post-marketing approval, long-term effects | Feasibility and safety | Effectiveness |
Design | Open-label | Randomized, controlled, often blinded | Randomized, controlled, typically blinded | Open-label | Open-label and randomized controlled | RCT most common and desirable; possible open-label and non-randomized |
Target population | HV and patients | Mostly patients, sometimes HV | Mostly patients | Only patients | Usually patients, possibly HV | Patients |
Sample size | Small (n = 20 to 100) | Medium (n = up to several hundred) | Large (n = usually around 300-3000, could be larger) | Large (n = usually more than 1000) | Relatively small (n = usually 10-50) | Larger but smaller than drug phase III (n = usually around 100-300) |
Duration | Short | Short (up to 1 year) | Moderate (around 2 years, including follow-ups) | Long (can go up to 3-4 years or an even longer follow-up) | Short (weeks to months) | Usually not as long as drug trials (months) |
Abbreviations: HV: healthy volunteers