Skip to main content
. 2018 Nov 20;8:17128. doi: 10.1038/s41598-018-35288-5

Table 1.

Characteristics of the 24 included studies (AECG as the diagnostic criteria).

Study Country Age range Male n (%) Study design Total pt # # of SS # of controls Scoring system +score of US
pSS sSS sSS Sicca HC
El Miedany et al.10 Egypt 47–66 9 (19%) cross-sectional cohort 87 47 20 20 0–3 ≥1
Niemela et al.11 Finland 18–67 1 (4%) cross-sectional cohort 81 27 27 27 0–4 ≥1
Su et al.12 China 44–64 not specified case-control 63 28 5 30 0–4 ≥1
Hocevar et al.13 Slovenia not specified not specified prospective cohort 218 68 150 0–48 ≥17
Yang et al.14 China 20–58 not specified retrospecctive study 41 41 0–4 ≥2
Song et al.15 China 26–65 12 (12%) case-control 128 98 30 0–4 ≥1
Salaffi et al.16 Italy 30–78 3 (4%) prospective cohort 156 77 79 0–16 ≥6
Poul et al.17 UK 20–85 5 (14%) prospective cohort 60 36 9 15 unknown
Milic et al.18 Serbia 21–78 4 (4%) prospective cohort 135 107 28 0–48 ≥19
Milic et al.19 Serbia 21–78 6 (5%) prospective cohort 245 115 44 50 36 0–12 ≥6
Xu et al.20 China 28–78 0 (0%) case-control 103 44 27 32 0–16 ≥8
Takagi et al.21 Japan 56 ± 13 20 (11%) prospective cohort 360 134 54 172 0–4 ≥1
Kong et al.22 China 27–63 6 (11%) case-control 84 15 39 30 0–48 unknown
Milic et al.23 Serbia 21–78 10 (7%) prospective cohort 190 140 50 0–16 ≥7
Cornec et al.24 France 56.8 ± 12.7 7 (9%) prospective cohort 158 78 80 0–4 ≥2
Theander et al.25 Sweden 20–91 not specified cross-sectional cohort 162 105 6 19 32 0–3 ≥2
Hammenfors et al.26 Norway not specified 6 (6%) cross-sectional cohort 97 97 0–3 ≥2
Baldini et al.27 Italy 47 ± 13 2 (4%) cross-sectional cohort 107 50 57 0–3 ≥2
Zhang et al.28 China 56.42 ± 10.21 4 (4%) prospective cohort 162 105 41 16 0–16 ≥7
0–48 ≥15
Lin et al.29 China 46.3 ± 13.1 6 (14) prospective cohort 94 44 14 36 0–12 ≥6
0–16 ≥6
0–48 ≥17
Zhou et al.30 China 32–80 1 (2%) case-control 85 53 32 0–4 ≥2
Zhou et al.31 China 32–82 2 (3%) case-control 165 71 45 49 0–4 ≥2
Chen et al.32 China 23–77 1 (2%) cross-sectional cohort 136 51 35 50 0–3 ≥1
Qi et al.33 China 49.75 ± 15.52 8 (6%) retrospective cohort 243 134 109 0–3 ≥2
0–16 ≥5

PSS = primary Sjögren’s syndrome; pt = patient; sSS = second Sjögren’s syndrome; HC = healthy control; US = ultrasonography.