Table 2.
Number of physicians providing the correct response (%; 95% CI) | ||
---|---|---|
Before seeing the evidence | After seeing the evidence | |
Knowledge on Benefit | ||
Reduction of ovarian cancer mortality? | ||
- Correct estimate (0 out of 1,000) | 68 (32.9; 26.5 to 39.7) | 160 (77.3; 71.0 to 82.8) |
- Overestimate | 128 (61.8; 54.8 to 68.5) | 33 (15.9; 11.2 to 21.7) |
- Underestimate | 11 (5.3; 2.7 to 9.3) | 14 (6.8; 3.7 to 11.1) |
Knowledge on Harms | ||
Do you think that ovarian cancer screening can also harm a woman? | ||
- Yes (correct) | 90 (43.5; 36.6 to 50.5) | 180 (87.0; 81.6 to 91.2) |
How many of every 1,000 women attending ovarian cancer screening over a period of 10 years do you think will receive a positive test result? (X out of 1,000 screened) | ||
- Correct estimate (101 women; ±10%: 91 to 111) | 24 (11.6; 7.6 to 16.8) | 66 (31.8; 25.6 to 38.7) |
- Underestimate (<91) | 171 (82.6; 76.7 to 87.5) | 138 (66.7; 59.8 to 73.0) |
- Overestimate (>111) | 12 (5.8; 3.0 to 9.9) | 3 (1.5; 0.3 to 4.2) |
How many of these positive test results do you think are false-positive test results? (%) | ||
- Correct estimate (95%; ±10%: 86% to 99%) | 21 (10.1; 6.4 to 15.1) | 67 (32.4; 26.0 to 39.2) |
- Underestimate (<86%) | 186 (89.9; 84.9 to 93.6) | 139 (67.1; 60.8 to 74.0) |
- Overestimate (100%) | — | 1 (0.5; 0.0 to 2.7) |
How many of these women who received a false-positive test result will have their ovaries removed as a consequence of further diagnostic work-up? (%) | ||
- Correct estimate (33%; ±10%: 30% to 37%) | 4 (1.9; 0.5 to 4.9) | 49 (23.7; 18.1 to 30.1) |
- Underestimate (<30%) | 84 (40.6; 33.8 to 47.6) | 47 (22.7; 17.2 to 29.0) |
- Overestimate (>37%) | 119 (57.5; 50.4 to 64.3) | 111 (53.6; 46.6 to 60.6) |
Do you think that the potential benefit of ovarian cancer screening (e.g., reduction of disease-specific mortality) outweighs the potential harms (e.g., false positives, overdiagnosis)? | ||
- No (correct) | 84 (40.4; 33.3 to 47.6) | 145 (70.0; 63.3 to 76.2) |