Skip to main content
. 2018 Nov 8;2018:6456724. doi: 10.1155/2018/6456724

Table 10.

Comparison of classification performance achieved by different synergy between feature selection methods and classification models.

Feature Selection (FS) Performance Metrics Classifiers
SVM ANN NB KNN LR LDA DT Proposed ECBDT
All features (No FS) Sensitivity 72.18% 75.19% 66.17% 72.93% 71.43% 75.19% 71.43% 74.48%
Specificity 95.47% 94.48% 93.41% 95.51% 94.82% 95.12% 94.10% 96.11%
F-score 57.31% 55.25% 46.93% 57.91% 54.44% 57.64% 51.91% 61.73%
Accuracy 94.21% 93.44% 91.95% 94.29% 93.57% 94.05% 92.88% 94.98%

PSO-ANN Sensitivity 73.65% 70.91% 69.16% 74.29% 69.23% 69.16% 71.83% 76.47%
Specificity 96.64% 96.11% 95.67% 96.72% 96.11% 95.67% 96.32% 97.09%
F-score 76.29% 77.33% 74.30% 75.96% 69.96% 74.30% 80.42% 80.28%
Accuracy 97.21% 97.25% 96.64% 97.21% 97.29% 96.64% 97.73% 97.73%

GA-ANN Sensitivity 87.97% 86.47% 64.66% 87.97% 87.22% 64.66% 86.47% 86.47%
Specificity 97.22% 97.09% 99.44% 98.20% 97.31% 99.44% 98.63% 98.93%
F-score 74.29% 72.78% 74.14% 80.14% 74.36% 74.14% 82.14% 84.25%
Accuracy 96.72% 96.52% 97.57% 97.65% 96.76% 97.57% 97.98% 98.26%

SA Sensitivity 85.71% 86.47% 90.23% 84.21% 84.96% 90.23% 84.21% 87.22%
Specificity 97.22% 97.73% 97.60% 97.52% 98.37% 97.60% 99.14% 99.27%
F-score 73.08% 76.41% 77.67% 73.93% 79.58% 77.67% 84.53% 87.22%
Accuracy 96.60% 97.13% 97.21% 96.80% 97.65% 97.21% 98.34% 98.62%

Proposed SA-ANN Sensitivity 85.71% 72.93% 72.93% 84.21% 79.70% 72.93% 86.47% 87.97%
Specificity 97.22% 99.70% 99.66% 97.52% 98.16% 99.66% 99.27% 99.40%
F-score 73.08% 81.86% 81.51% 73.93% 75.18% 81.51% 86.79% 87.79%
Accuracy 96.60% 98.26% 98.22% 96.80% 97.17% 98.22% 98.58% 98.70%