Table 10.
Feature Selection (FS) | Performance Metrics | Classifiers | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SVM | ANN | NB | KNN | LR | LDA | DT | Proposed ECBDT | ||
All features (No FS) | Sensitivity | 72.18% | 75.19% | 66.17% | 72.93% | 71.43% | 75.19% | 71.43% | 74.48% |
Specificity | 95.47% | 94.48% | 93.41% | 95.51% | 94.82% | 95.12% | 94.10% | 96.11% | |
F-score | 57.31% | 55.25% | 46.93% | 57.91% | 54.44% | 57.64% | 51.91% | 61.73% | |
Accuracy | 94.21% | 93.44% | 91.95% | 94.29% | 93.57% | 94.05% | 92.88% | 94.98% | |
| |||||||||
PSO-ANN | Sensitivity | 73.65% | 70.91% | 69.16% | 74.29% | 69.23% | 69.16% | 71.83% | 76.47% |
Specificity | 96.64% | 96.11% | 95.67% | 96.72% | 96.11% | 95.67% | 96.32% | 97.09% | |
F-score | 76.29% | 77.33% | 74.30% | 75.96% | 69.96% | 74.30% | 80.42% | 80.28% | |
Accuracy | 97.21% | 97.25% | 96.64% | 97.21% | 97.29% | 96.64% | 97.73% | 97.73% | |
| |||||||||
GA-ANN | Sensitivity | 87.97% | 86.47% | 64.66% | 87.97% | 87.22% | 64.66% | 86.47% | 86.47% |
Specificity | 97.22% | 97.09% | 99.44% | 98.20% | 97.31% | 99.44% | 98.63% | 98.93% | |
F-score | 74.29% | 72.78% | 74.14% | 80.14% | 74.36% | 74.14% | 82.14% | 84.25% | |
Accuracy | 96.72% | 96.52% | 97.57% | 97.65% | 96.76% | 97.57% | 97.98% | 98.26% | |
| |||||||||
SA | Sensitivity | 85.71% | 86.47% | 90.23% | 84.21% | 84.96% | 90.23% | 84.21% | 87.22% |
Specificity | 97.22% | 97.73% | 97.60% | 97.52% | 98.37% | 97.60% | 99.14% | 99.27% | |
F-score | 73.08% | 76.41% | 77.67% | 73.93% | 79.58% | 77.67% | 84.53% | 87.22% | |
Accuracy | 96.60% | 97.13% | 97.21% | 96.80% | 97.65% | 97.21% | 98.34% | 98.62% | |
| |||||||||
Proposed SA-ANN | Sensitivity | 85.71% | 72.93% | 72.93% | 84.21% | 79.70% | 72.93% | 86.47% | 87.97% |
Specificity | 97.22% | 99.70% | 99.66% | 97.52% | 98.16% | 99.66% | 99.27% | 99.40% | |
F-score | 73.08% | 81.86% | 81.51% | 73.93% | 75.18% | 81.51% | 86.79% | 87.79% | |
Accuracy | 96.60% | 98.26% | 98.22% | 96.80% | 97.17% | 98.22% | 98.58% | 98.70% |