Skip to main content
. 2018 Nov;10(Suppl 32):S3728–S3739. doi: 10.21037/jtd.2018.10.48

Table 1. Included prospective randomized trial characteristics.

The 1st author, year Intervention Control Participant country Trial design No. randomized No. allocated intervention No. allocated control Procedures Incision
Allen, 2004 Progel (biodegradable polymeric sealant, human serum albumin-USP) Standard care USA Multi-center, open-label, stratified group 161 103 58 Wedge, segmentectomy, lobectomy, bilobectomy, LVRS, decortication Open
Anegg, 2006 TachoSil (equine collagen patch coated with human fibrinogen-thrombin) Standard care Austria Single-center, open-label, parallel group 152 75 77 Segmentectomy, lobectomy Open
Belcher, 2010 Vivostat (autologous fibrin sealant) BioGlue (mixture of bovine serum albumin and glutaraldehyde) UK Single-center, single-blind, parallel group 103 53 50 Wedge, segmentectomy, lobectomy, bilobectomy NR
Cardillo, 2012 Fibrin sealant Standard care Italy Multi-centre, open-label, parallel group 185 91 94 Segmentectomy, lobectomy, other Open
Belboul, 2004 Vivostat (autologous fibrin sealant) Standard care Sweden Single-center, open-label, parallel group 40 20 20 Lobectomy Open
D’Andrilli, 2009 CoSeal (synthetic polyethylene glycol matrix) Standard care Italy Single-center, open-label, parallel group 203 102 101 Wedge, segmentectomy, lobectomy, bilobectomy, sleeve lobectomy Open
De Leyn, 2011 PleuraSeal (synthetic hydrogel tissue sealant) Standard care Belgium, Austria, The Netherlands, UK, Switzerland Multi-centre, open-label, parallel group 121 63 59 Segmentectomy, lobectomy Open
Fabian, 2003 HemaMyst fibrin glue Standard care USA Single-center, double-blind, parallel group 100 50 50 Wedge, segmentectomy, lobectomy, bilobectomy Open
Filosso, 2012 TachoSil (equine collagen patch coated with human fibrinogen-thrombin) Standard care in re-do surgery Italy Single-center, open-label, parallel group 24 13 11 Completion lobectomy Open
Gonfiotti, 2011 Fibrin sealant Standard care Italy Multi-centre, open-label, parallel group 185 91 94 Segmentectomy, lobectomy Open
Kýlýç, 2011 Tisseal (homologous fibrin sealant) Vivostat (autologous fibrin sealant) Turkey Single-center, open-label, parallel group 80 40 40 Wedge, lobectomy Open n=33; VATS n=24
Lang, 2004 TachoComb (fleece bound fibrin glue sealant) Standard care Austria, Hungary, Germany, Sweden Multi-centre, open-label, parallel group 189 96 93 Lobectomy Open
Lequaglie, 2012 CoSeal (synthetic polyethylene glycol matrix) Standard care Italy Single-center, open-label, parallel group 222 111 111 Wedge, segmentectomy, lobectomy, bilobectomy, decortication NR
Marta, 2010 TachoSil (equine collagen patch coated with human fibrinogen-thrombin) Standard care Germany, Italy, Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Hungary, Sweden, Switzerland Multi-centre, open-label, parallel group 299 148 151 Lobectomy, bilobectomy Open
Moser, 2008 Vivostat (autologous fibrin sealant) Standard care Switzerland Single-center, double-blind, parallel group 50 25 25 Bilateral LVRS VATS
Porte, 2001 Synthetic surgical lung sealant Standard care Single-center, open-label, parallel group 124 62 62 Lobectomy, bilobectomy Open
Rena, 2009 TachoSil (equine collagen patch coated with human fibrinogen-thrombin) Standard care Italy Single-center, open-label, parallel group 60 30 30 Lobectomy Open
Tan, 2011 CoSeal (synthetic polyethylene glycol matrix) Standard care UK Single-center, single-blind, parallel group 121 61 60 Lobectomy, bilobectomy Open
Tansley, 2006 BioGlue (mixture of bovine serum albumin and glutaraldehyde) Standard care UK Single-center, single-blind, parallel group 52 25 27 Segmentectomy, lobectomy, other Open
Wain, 2001 Synthetic, bioresorbable surgical sealant; water soluble polyethylene glycol-based gel Standard care USA Multi-centre, open-label, parallel group 172 117 55 Wedge, segmentectomy, lobectomy Open
Wong, 1997 Tisseal (homologous fibrin sealant) Standard care UK Single-center, open-label, parallel group 66 33 33 Segmentectomy, lobectomy, decortication Open

No., number; LVRS, lung volume reduction surgery; NR, not reported; VATS, video-assisted thoracic surgery.