Table 3.
Diagnostic instrument | Outcomes measured | Reported associations with prenatal marijuana exposurea | Age at assessment | Article (Study, first author, year) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Bayley Scale of Infant Development | Mental Development Index: sensory/perceptual
abilities, acquisition of object constancy, memory, learning, problem
solving, vocalization and beginning of verbal
communication Psychomotor Development Index: degree of body control, large muscle coordination, finer manipulatory skills of the hands and fingers, dynamic movement, postural imitation, and the ability to recognize objects by sense of touch (stereognosis) |
No significant associations | 1 year and 2 years | OPPS, Fried, 1988 |
Infant Behavior Record | Primary Cognition Composite Score: object orientation, goal directedness, attention span, reactivity, and vocalization | Positive association | 1 year | OPPS, Fried, 1988 |
No results reported. | 2 years | OPPS, Fried, 1988 |
||
Extraversion Score: social orientation to the
examiner, cooperativeness, and general emotional tone Visual and auditory sensory systems |
No associations | 1 year and 2 years | OPPS, Fried, 1988 |
|
Reynell Developmental Language Scale | Comprehension | Negative association | 2 years | OPPS, Fried, 1988 |
Expression | No associations | 2, 3, and 4 years | OPPS, Fried, 1988; 1990 | |
Denver Developmental Scale | Gross motor development | Negative association | 3 years | NMIHS, Faden, 2000 |
Adaptive functioning, language, and fine motor development | No associations | |||
McCarthy Scales of Children’s Abilities | General Cognitive Index (memory, verbal development, perception, and quantitative abilities) | No associations | 3 years | OPPS, Fried, 1990 |
Negative association | 4 years | OPPS, Fried, 1990 | ||
No associations | 4, 5 and 6 years | Jamaica study, Hayes, 1991; OPPS, Fried, 1992 |
||
Motor performance score | Positive association in moderately exposed children compared to unexposed and heavily exposed | 3 years | OPPS, Fried, 1990 |
|
No associations | 4, 5 and 6 years | OPPS, Fried, 1990; 1992; Jamaica study, Hayes, 1991 |
||
Memory score | No associations | 3 years | OPPS, Fried, 1990 | |
Negative association | 4 years | OPPS, Fried, 1990 | ||
No associations | 4, 5 and 6 years | Jamaica study, Hayes, 1991; OPPS, Fried, 1992 |
||
Verbal score | No associations | 3 years | OPPS, Fried, 1990 | |
Negative association | 4 years | OPPS, Fried, 1990 | ||
No associations | 4, 5 and 6 years | Jamaica study, Hayes, 1991; OPPS, Fried, 1992 |
||
Quantitative score | Negative association | 3 years | OPPS, Fried, 1990 | |
No associations | 4 years | OPPS, Fried, 1990 | ||
No associations | 4, 5 and 6 years | Jamaica study, Hayes, 1991; OPPS, Fried, 1992 |
||
Perceptual score | No associations | 3 years | OPPS, Fried, 1990 | |
Negative association | 4 years | OPPS, Fried, 1990 | ||
No associations | 4, 5 and 6 years | Jamaica study, Hayes, 1991; OPPS, Fried, 1992 |
||
McCarthy Scales of Children’s Abilities subset adapted for use with children 3 to 12 years of age, truncated. | Category fluency (language development) | No associations | 4 years | Prenatal cocaine exposure study, Noland, 2003 |
Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale, 4 Ed. | Composite score (IQ) | Negative association | 3 years | MHPCD, Day, 1994 |
No associations | 4, 6 and 9 years | Developmental effects of prenatal substance exposure study, Bennett, 2008 | ||
Not reported | 6 years | MHPCD, Leech, 1999 | ||
Negative association | 6 years | MHPCD, Goldschmidt, 2008 | ||
Short-term memory | Negative association | 3 years | MHPCD, Day, 1994 | |
No associations | 4, 6 and 9 years | Developmental effects of prenatal substance exposure study, Bennett, 2008 | ||
Negative association | 6 years | MHPCD, Goldschmidt, 2008 | ||
Verbal reasoning | Negative association | 3 years | MHPCD, Day, 1994 | |
No associations | 4, 6 and 9 years | Developmental effects of prenatal substance exposure study, Bennett, 2008 | ||
Negative association | 6 years | MHPCD, Goldschmidt, 2008 | ||
Quantitative reasoning | No associations | 3 years | MHPCD, Day, 1994 | |
No associations | 4, 6 and 9 years | Developmental effects of prenatal substance exposure study, Bennett, 2008 | ||
Negative association | 6 years | MHPCD, Goldschmidt, 2008 | ||
Abstract/visual reasoning | Negative association | 3 years | MHPCD, Day, 1994 | |
No associations | 4, 6 and 9 years | Developmental effects of prenatal substance exposure study, Bennett, 2008 | ||
No associations | 6 years | MHPCD, Goldschmidt, 2008 | ||
Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence, III | Verbal IQ, attention | Not reported | 4 years | Prenatal cocaine exposure study, Noland, 2003; 2005 |
No associations | 4.5 years | IDEAL, Chakraborty, 2015 | ||
Finger sequencing task adapted by Welsh for use with children. | Motor planning | No associations | 4 years | Prenatal cocaine exposure study, Noland, 2003 |
Pegboard test | Manual dexterity and bimanual coordination | No associations | 4 years | OPPS, Fried, 1990 |
Picture deletion task for preschoolers-modified (Corkum) | Attention | Non-significant negative association | 4 years | Prenatal cocaine exposure study, Noland, 2005 |
Tactile Form Recognition Task | Stereognosis | No associations | 4 years | OPPS, Fried, 1990 |
Tapping Inhibition (test of frontal lobe functioning (Luria) adapted by Diamond and Taylor for use with children 3.5 through 7 years of age) | Inhibitory control (Ability to override their natural, habitual, or dominant behavioral response to a stimulus in order to implement more adaptive goal-oriented behaviors) | No associations | 4 years | Prenatal cocaine exposure study, Noland, 2003 |
Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test | Vocabulary | Negative association | 4 years | OPPS, Fried, 1990 |
No associations | 5 years, 6 years and 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1992; 1997 | ||
Random Dot Kinematograms | Global motor perception (higher-level processing in visual cortex) | Positive association in children who were not prenatally exposed to alcohol. | 4.5 years | IDEAL, Chakraborty, 2015 |
Conners Parent Questionnaire |
Impulsivity hyperactivity | Non-significant negative association | 6 years | OPPS, Fried, 1992 |
No associations | 6–9 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991 | ||
Hyperactivity index, learning problems, and psychosomatic problems | No associations | 6–9 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991 | |
Anxiety, conduct problems | Non-significant negative association | 6–9 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991 | |
Gordon Diagnostic System | Sustained attention and self-control | Negative association | 6 years | OPPS, Fried, 1992 |
Impulsivity | Negative association | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1998 | |
Continuous Performance Task | Errors of commission
(impulsivity) |
Not reported | 4 years | Prenatal cocaine exposure study, Noland, 2005 |
Negative association | 6 years and 10 years | MHPCD, Leech, 1999; Richardson, 2001 | ||
Errors of omission (inattentiveness) | Not reported | 4 years | Prenatal cocaine exposure study, Noland, 2005 | |
Positive association | 6 years | MHPCD, Leech, 1999 | ||
The Sentence Memory Test | Immediate auditory memory and auditory attention for sentences | No associations | 6 years | OPPS, Fried, 1992 |
The Target Test | Visual-spatial memory | No associations | 6 years | OPPS, Fried, 1992 |
The Yale Child Study Center Attention Task | Attention and inhibitory control | No associations | 6, 9, and 11 years | Developmental effects of prenatal substance exposure study, Carmody, 2011 |
Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills | Perceptual Quotient, Visual Discrimination, Visual Sequential Memory | Non-significant negative association | 6–9 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991 |
No associations | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 2000 | ||
Visual Closure, Visual Figure Ground, Visual Form Constancy, Visual Memory, and Visual Spatial Relations | No associations |
6–9 and 9–12 years |
OPPS, O’Connell, 1991; Fried, 2000 | |
Trail Making Test | Visual scanning, visuospatial sequencing, attention, mental flexibility, and motor function | Non-significant negative association | 6–9 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991 |
No associations | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 2000 | ||
Wide Range Achievement
Test-revised |
Reading, arithmetic, spelling | No associations | 6–9 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991 |
Negative association | 10 years | MHPCD, Goldschmidt, 2004 | ||
Reading | No associations | 6–9 and 9–12 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991; Fried, 1997 | |
Knox Cube Test | Visual attention, visual memory and visual sequencing | No associations |
6–9 and 9–12 years |
OPPS, O’Connell, 1991; Fried, 2000 |
Woodcock Reading Mastery Test | Passage comprehension | No associations | 6–9 and 9–12 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991; Fried, 1997 |
Beery Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration | Visual-motor integration (copy geometric forms into a notepad) | No significant associations | 6–9 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991 |
No associations | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 2000 | ||
Draw a man | Intelligence (score is based on detail, proportion and coordination) | No significant associations | 6–9 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991 |
Finger tapping | Motor control, speed and lateral coordination | No significant associations | 6–9 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991 |
Stroop Interference | Tests the ability to sort and selectively react to information: e.g. word ‘red’ is printed in green ink. The child must say loudly the color of the text and not the word. | Non-significant negative association | 6–9 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991 |
Test of Language Development (Primary syntax quotient score) | Ability to generate acceptable sentences | Non-significant negative association | 6–9 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991 |
Auditory Working Memory | Working memory | Non-significant negative association | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1998 |
Category Test | Problem-solving capacity | Negative association | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1998 |
Fluency Test | Verbal fluency (number of words starting with ‘C’ and ‘P’ produced in 60 sec) | No associations | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1997; 1998 |
Oral Cloze Task | Ability to understand the basic grammatical structure of English based on auditory process | No associations | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1997 |
Pseudoword Task | Reading and decoding abilities | Non-significant negative association in children with moderate exposure compared to children with no or heavy exposure | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1997 |
Seashore Rhythm Test | Rhythm discrimination | No associations | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1997 |
Tactile Performance Task | Motor abilities and motor memory (blindfolded, place wooden blocks into properly shaped holes) | No associations | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1998 |
Wechsler Intelligence Scale for
Children, 3rd ed. |
Full scale IQ | No associations | 6–9 and 9–12 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991; Fried, 1997; 1998; 2000 |
Information | No associations | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1997 | |
Non-significant negative association | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1998 | ||
Verbal IQ, Verbal Comprehension Index | No associations | 6–9 and 9–12 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991; Fried, 1997; 1998 | |
Similarities, Vocabulary | No associations | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1997; 1998 | |
Performance IQ | No associations | 6–9 and 9–12 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991; Fried, 1998 | |
Arithmetic, Processing Speed Index | No associations | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1998 | |
Freedom from Distractibility Index | No associations | 6–9 and 9–12 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991; Fried, 1998; 2000 | |
Coding (discrimination and memory of visual symbols); Symbol Search (visual scanning), and Digit Span (memory) | No associations | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1998; 2000 | |
Comprehension | Negative association | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1998 | |
Mazes (rudimentary
planning) |
Negative association | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1998 | |
No associations | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 2000 | ||
Perceptual Organization Index (a summary index of picture completion, picture arrangement, block design, and object assembly) | No association | 6–9 and 9–12 years | OPPS, O’Connell, 1991; Fried, 1998 | |
Negative association | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 2000 | ||
Object Assembly | Negative association | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1998; 2000 | |
Block Design | Negative association | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1998; 2000 | |
Picture Arrangement | No associations | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1998; 2000 | |
Picture Completion | No associations | 9–12 years | OPPS, Fried, 1998; 2000 | |
Child Behavior Checklist | Attention problems | No associations | 10 years | MHPCD, Goldschmidt, 2000 |
Severe discrepancy between ability (Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale, 4ed.) | Underachieving | Negative association | 10 years | MHPCD, Goldschmidt, 2004 |
Swanson, Noland, and Pelham Assessment | Impulsivity, hyperactivity, inattention symptoms | Negative association | 10 years | MHPCD, Goldschmidt, 2000 |
Teacher’s Report Form | Attention problems | No associations | 10 years | MHPCD, Goldschmidt, 2000 |
Teacher’s assessment of the child in language arts, history, math, and science. | Educational performance | Negative association | 10 years | MHPCD, Goldschmidt, 2004 |
Peabody Individual Achievement Test-revised | Reading comprehension | Negative association | 10 years | MHPCD, Goldschmidt, 2004 |
Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning | Design memory, screening index | Negative association | 10 years | MHPCD, Richardson, 2001 |
Story memory, verbal learning | No association | 10 years | MHPCD, Richardson, 2001 |
Negative associations were defined as statistically significant association in analyses adjusted for potential confounders between prenatal marijuana exposure and diminished neuropsychological function, e.g. lower scores on reading comprehension or memory; or higher scores on errors, impulsivity, inattention, or underachievement (p<0.05), regardless of the trimester of exposure. Positive associations were defined as statistically significant associations in adjusted analyses between prenatal marijuana exposure and enhanced neuropsychological function, e.g. higher scores on reading comprehension or memory; or lower scores on errors, impulsivity, inattention, or underachievement (p<0.05), regardless of the trimester of exposure. Non-significant negative and positive associations were defined as statistically significant negative or positive associations found in bivariate analyses but not in adjusted analyses (p≥0.05). No association the analyses did not find associations between prenatal marijuana exposure and neuropsychological functions in bivariate and adjusted analyses.