Skip to main content
. 2018 Nov 29;2018(11):CD012776. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012776.pub2
Risk of bias component Low Unclear High
Recruitment bias No participants recruited after clusters randomized No or unclear information reported
Recruitment bias not applicable to trial design as it is related to human participants
Paricipants recruited to trial after clusters randomized
Mosquito group comparability Mosquito populations comparable No or unclear information reported Mosquito populations comparable
Collectors blinded Outcomes assessed blinded No or unclear information reported
Outcomes assessed not blinded, but this is unlikely to influence the results
Outcomes assessed not blinded, and this is likely to influence the results
Household blinded Outcomes assessed blinded No or unclear information reported
If outcomes assessed were not blinded, but this is unlikely to influence the results, we will judge this to be low risk.
Outcomes assessed not blinded, and this is likely to influence the results
If outcomes assessed were not blinded, but this is unlikely to influence the results, we will judge this to be low risk.
Treatment allocation Treatments randomized No or unclear information reported Treatments not randomized
Allocation concealment Allocation concealment procedures were adhered to. No or unclear information reported
Allocation concealment procedures where not adhered to, however this is unlikely to affect the results.
Allocation procedures were not adhered to and this is likely to have affected the results.
Incomplete outcome data addressed No or low missing data, reason for missing data is unlikely to be related to the true outcome No or unclear information reported High missing data, reason for missing data is likely to be related to the true outcome
Raw data reported Raw data reported No or unclear information reported Raw data not reported
Clusters lost to follow‐up No complete clusters lost from trial No or unclear information as to whether clusters were lost from trial At least one cluster lost from trial
Selective reporting No selective reporting, all measured outcomes reported in results No or unclear information on whether all measured outcomes were reported in results Selective reporting; not all measured outcomes were reported in results
Correct statistical methods; adjusted for clustering Clustering was taken into account and statistical methods adjusted for clustering No or unclear information as to whether clustering was taken into account for statistical methods. Trial did not take clustering into account for statistical methods
Conflicting interests No conflict of interest is stated No or unclear information reported Conflict of interest stated