Skip to main content
. 2018 Nov 16;18(11):4005. doi: 10.3390/s18114005

Table 3.

Comparison of other recently published works and this work.

Ref. Resonator Type Operating Frequency Sensitivity (%/εr) Relative Size Structure Measurement Type Maximum Error
[14] Cylindrical dielectric resonator 10.5 GHz 0.0628 NA Non-planar Non-invasive and contactless 13.4%
[43] SIW cavity resonator 8.96 GHz 0.0188 (0.46λ0×~×0.047λ0) § Planar Non-invasive and contactless 2.93%
[44] Complementary SRR-loaded quarter mode SIW resonator 3.82 GHz 0.407 NR Planar Non-invasive and contactless NR
[45]-1 Microstrip SRR 3.1035 GHz 0.026 0.37λ0×0.37λ0×0.016λ0 Planar Non-invasive and contactless 2.3%
[45]-2 3.1114 GHz 0.00655 2.9%
[46] Coupled impedance resonator 1.37 GHz 0.13 (0.23λ0×~×0.002λ0) Planar Non-invasive and contactless NR
[47] Coupled ring resonator 2.29 GHz 0.222 NR Planar Non-invasive and contactless NR
[48] SIW cavity resonator 17.08 GHz 0.16 1.7λ0×1.99λ0×0.147λ0 Planar Non-invasive and contactless NR
[49] SIW cavity resonator 5.8513 GHz 0.00683 1.46λ0×0.64λ0×0.019λ0 Planar Invasive 5%
This work Square SIW re-entrant cavity resonator 2.18875 GHz 0.366 0.4λ0×0.36λ0×0.041λ0 Planar Non-invasive and contactless 3.24%

λ0 is the free space wavelength at operating frequency; § Length of the sensor is not mentioned in [43]; The overall width of the sensor is not given in [46].