Skip to main content
. 2014 Aug 26;19(9):13104–13121. doi: 10.3390/molecules190913104

Table 1.

Results of the HSI classification analysis using the (PLS-DA) model in comparison to the product label.

Product Product Label Claim HSI Species Predictions (%)
E. angustifolia E. purpurea E. pallida No Class
1 E. purpurea (herb, root) & E. angustifolia herb 1.9 89.8 a 0 8.3
2 E. angustifolia root extract 0 0 0.2 99.8 b
3 E. purpurea root & aerial parts 89.3 a 2.6 0.2 7.9
4 E. purpurea Herba & Radix dry concentrate 0 0 0 100 b
5 E. purpurea & E. angustifolia 14.3 7.7 1.2 76.8 b
6 E. purpurea root & E. angustifolia root 94.6 a 5.4 0 0.1
7 Echinacea purpurea extract 0 0 0 100 b
8 E. purpurea Herba & E. purpurea Radix 0 0 0 100 b
9 E. pallida 0 72.2 a 7.4 20.4
10 E. purpurea root & E. angustifolia root 86.7 a 12.6 0 0.7
11 E. angustifolia root 99.5 a 0 0.1 0.4
12 E. purpurea herb 0.2 73.2 a 0.2 26.4
13 E. pallida (outer label) & E. purpurea (inner label) 1.3 22.9 2.4 73.3 b
14 Echinacea aerial powder & root powder 9.2 90.1 a 0 0.7
15 E. angustifolia root & rhizome 0 0 0 100 b
16 E. purpurea stem, leaf, flower 61.8 a 12.1 0 26.1
17 E. purpurea root 0.2 95.4 a 0 4.4
18 Echinacea blend (angustifolia, pallida, purpurea) 0.1 92.4 a 2 5.6
19 Echinacea leaf powder & standardised extract 4.9 88.5 a 0 6.6
20 Echinacea, Goldenseal, Elderberry, Garlic & Parsley 16.3 8.1 9.4 66.3 b
21 E. purpurea leaf (authentic raw material) 0.1 90.2 a 6.5 3.3
22 E. angustifolia root (authentic raw material) 89.1 a 3.5 0.4 7
23 E. purpurea root (authentic raw material) 0 97.5 a 0 2.5
24 E. angustifolia leaf (authentic raw material) 64.2 a 6.4 1.8 27.5

a The formulation was predicted to contain the indicated species in highest proportions. b The formulation was predicted to contain little or no authentic Echinacea raw material.