Skip to main content
. 2018 Nov 28;8(11):e020062. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-020062

Table 1.

Characteristics of included studies

Author (year) Design Study setting No. of patients Mean age, years Country Male, % Depression prevalence, % Depression assessment Compared groups Source of estimates Adjusted factors
Katon et al 21 Cross-sectional Community 4193 65 USA 51 20.5 PHQ-9 Insulin versus non-drug Adjusted Age, sex, education, marital status, employment, race, BMI and smoking, Rx Risk Score, HbA1c, duration of diabetes, treatment intensity, number of complications
Bell et al 20 Cross-sectional Community 696 74 USA 50.7 15.8 CES-D Insulin versus oral medication; insulin versus non-drug Adjusted Age, sex, ethnicity, education, marital status, income, diabetes duration, number of medications, BMI, HbA1c, chronic conditions, PCS Score
Noh et al 17 Hospital-based Hospital 204 53 Korean 53 32.4 BDI Insulin versus oral medication Adjusted Age, sex, BMI, duration of diabetes, HbA1c, occupation, education, marital status, family history of diabetes, hypertension, diabetic complications, cerebrovascular disease, IHD
Hermanns et al 40 Cross-sectional Hospital 236 52.2 Germany 60.6 33 BDI; CES-D Insulin versus non-insulin Unadjusted NA
Pawaskar et al 31 Prospective cohort Medicare Health Maintenance Organisation 792 72 USA 44 17.3 CES Insulin versus sulfonylurea Adjusted Age, sex, number of prescriptions, antidiabetic medication, perceived health status, health-related quality of life, number of hospitalisations, ER visits
Li et al 18 Cross-sectional Surveillance Programme 16 651 ≥18 USA 42 14.4 PHQ Insulin versus non-insulin Unadjusted NA
Ali et al 33 Cross-sectional Hospital 3845 NA Mixed (South Asia and UK) 52.8 9.3 Medical records Insulin versus non-insulin Adjusted Age, gender, comorbidities, complications, insulin and oral anti-diabetic medication use, BMI, HbA1c, duration of diabetes and deprivation
Raval et al 36 Cross-sectional Hospital 300 54 India 49 41 PHQ-9 Insulin versus non-insulin Adjusted Age, gender, obesity, diabetic complications, blood pressure, duration of disease, income, education, BMI, HbA1c, diabetic complications, dyslipidaemia, number of medicines
Zuberi et al 42 Cross-sectional Hospital 286 52 Pakistan 39.2 50 HADS Insulin versus oral medication Unadjusted NA
Stanković et al 41 Cross-sectional Hospital 90 55.5 Serbia 34.4 51.1 PHQ, BDI or interview Insulin versus oral medication Unadjusted NA
Lynch et al 43 Cross-sectional Hospital 201 NA USA 27.4 19.9 CES-D Insulin versus non-insulin Unadjusted NA
Osme et al 44 Cross-sectional Outpatient clinic 138 ≥30 Brazil 27.5 44.6 HAD Insulin versus non-insulin Unadjusted NA
Trento et al 45 Cross-sectional Outpatient clinic 498 67.6 Italy 52.6 14.2 ZSDS Insulin versus non-insulin Unadjusted NA
Roy et al 37 Cross-sectional Outpatient clinic 417 53.2 Bangladesh 50.6 34 PHQ-9 Insulin versus oral medication+diet;
insulin+oral
medication versus oral
medication+diet
Adjusted Age, gender, education, income, region, CVD, hypertension, diabetic complications, BMI, HbA1c
Joseph et al 46 Cross-sectional Hospital 230 53.6 India 51.7 45.2 PHQ-9 Insulin versus oral medication Unadjusted NA
Hayashino et al 47 Cross-sectional Hospital 3573 66 Japan 61.1 3.4 PHQ-9 Insulin versus oral medication or diet Unadjusted NA
Gorska-Ciebiada et al 34 Cross-sectional Outpatient clinic 276 74 Poland 46 29.7 GDS Insulin versus oral medication Adjusted Age, sex, education, marital status, smoking, physical activity, duration of diabetes, BMI, HbA1c, lipid levels, diabetic complications, previous HA or use of HA drugs, hyperlipidaemia, number of comorbid conditions, hypoglycaemia
Sweileh et al 48 Cross-sectional Hospital 294 60 Palestine 44.2 40.2 BDI Insulin versus non-insulin Unadjusted NA
YY Zhang et al 52 Cross-sectional Hospital 2538 56.4 China 53 6.1 PHQ-9 Insulin versus oral drugs Unadjusted NA
Rodriguez Calvin et al 51 Cross-sectional Hospital 275 64.5 Spain 56.4 32.7 BDI Insulin versus oral medication Unadjusted NA
Camara et al 35 Cross-sectional Outpatient clinic 491 58 Guinea 37 34.4 HADS Insulin versus oral medication Adjusted Age, HbA1c, hypertension, BMI, residence zone, socioeconomic status
Sun et al 39 Cross-sectional Community 229 047 57.4 China 34.4 5.9 PHQ-9 Insulin versus oral medication or diet Adjusted Age, sex, BMI, HbA1c, smoking, alcohol, physical activity, education, occupation, marital status, self-report cardiometabolic disorders, diabetes treatment, diabetes duration
WJ Zhang et al 32 Cross-sectional Hospital 412 59.8 China 50.2 5.7 BDI Insulin versus oral medication Adjusted Age, gender, education, marital status, occupation, insurance, HbA1c, BMI, DM history, diabetic complications, duration of DM, smoking, alcohol, exercise, sleeping hours
Luca et al 50 Cross-sectional Hospital 128 64.7 Italy 58.6 50.8 HAM-D Insulin versus oral medication or diet Unadjusted NA
Kikuchi et al 49 Cross-sectional Community 4218 65.5 Japan 57.1 10.6 CES-D Insulin versus non-insulin Unadjusted NA
Jacob et al 38 Cross-sectional Community 90 412 65.5 Germany 50.2 30.3 Medical records Insulin versus non-insulin Adjusted Age, gender, insurance, diabetic complications, CVD, HbA1c
Cols-Sagarra et al 53 Cross-sectional Community 411 70.8 Spain 46.2 29.2 PHQ-9 Insulin versus oral medications or diet Unadjusted NA
Habtewold et al 54 Cross-sectional Hospital 276 44 Ethiopia 47 44.7 PHQ-9 Insulin versus oral medication Unadjusted NA

BDI, Beck Depression Inventory; BMI, body mass index; CES-D, Centre for Epidemiologic Studies-Depression; CVD, cardiovascular disease; DM, diabetes mellitus; ER, emergency room; GDS, Geriatric Depression Scale; HADS, Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale; HAM-D, Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression; IHD, ischaemic heart disease; PCS, Physical Component Summary Score; PHQ, Patient Health Questionnaire; ZSDS, Zung Self-Rating Depression Scale.