Table 3.
Name of segmentation method | Description of method | Benefits | Limitations |
---|---|---|---|
Edge detection method | Depends on discontinuity detection; generally aims to situate points with less or more rapid gray-level changes | • A human-like approach • Appropriate methods to get the best picture disproportionate area |
• Not good with images where edges are unclearly defined • Not suitable for images whose edges are not completely clear • Not suitable for images with a large number of edges • It has the lowest noise compared to other methods |
Thresholding method | Requires images with diffident sharp edges, each of which fits a single area | • No need for prior knowledge about the image • Minimum complexity of computation |
• Not good for image with no clear peaks • Not suitable for images that do not have any clear edge • Do not consider distances, so there is no guarantee for the division of continuous areas |
Region-dependent method | • The same pixel in nearby areas are similar • Counting the growing area, separating, assembling or reversing them |
• Does well if region homogeneity norm is painless to define • Extra noise resistant as compared to edge detection method |
• The amount of memory and calculation time is very costly • Region growing relies on seed region selection and sequence by which regions, pixels are inspected • Output segments by region splitting emerge too square because of splitting format |
Fuzzy method | Uses operators, mathematics, properties and rules of fuzzy inference | • Fuzzy membership function can be used to represent the degree of low properties or linguistic phrases | • Determining the fuzzy membership function is not easy • The calculations used in the fuzzy method can be difficult |
Neural network method | Uses for clustering or categorization | • Does not require writing tedious programs • Could entirely exploit the parallel nature of neural net |
• Need a lot of time to train • Initialization might affect the outcome |
Note: Data adapted from Pradeep et al.16