Table 1.
Study | N | Sample✝ | Gender (% female) | % OW/OBa | Ethnicity✝ | Location | Study type | Healthy strategies | Unhealthy strategies | Extreme strategies |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Calderon et al. (2004) [18] | 146 | 10th grade | 64 | 27 (Mb) | 8% Caucasian 27% Asian-American 4% African-American 48% Hispanic 0% Native-American 12% Other |
California | CSc | Eating smaller portions | Skipping meals, fad or crash diet | Diet aids |
Childress et al. (1993) [24] | 3129 | 5th to 8th grade | 51 | N/A | 64% Caucasian 21% African-American 7% Other 8% N/A |
South Carolina | CS | Exercise | Fasting | Vomiting, diuretics, diet pills, laxatives |
Davis & Lambert (2000) [25] | 1994 | 5th grade | 51 | 34 (M) | 100% Native-American | New Mexico | CS | Exercise, “eating a little less” | Strict diet | N/A |
French et al. (1995) [46] | 852 | 7th to 10th grade | 100 | N/A | 89% Caucasian 4% Mixed Race 3%Asian-American < 1%Native-American < 1%African-American < 1% Hispanic |
Minnesota | Ld | Low-calorie diet | N/A | Vomiting, diet pills, laxatives, enemas |
Kilpatrick et al. (1999) [19] | 6504 | 7th to 12th grade | 53 | 22 (M) 31 (Pe) |
62% Caucasian 23% African-American 9% Hispanic 3% Asian-American 3% Native-American |
USA† | CS | Exercise | N/A | Vomiting, diet pills, laxatives |
Koff & Rierdan (1991) [45] | 206 | 6th grade | 100 | 21 (P) | 100% Caucasian | Massachusetts | CS | Exercise, avoid fattening foods | Skipping meals, fasting | N/A |
Krowchuk et al. (1998) [23] | 2331 | 6th to 8th grade | 49 | 24 (P) | 64% Caucasian 28% African-American 2% Hispanic 1% Asian-American 2% Native-American 3% Other |
North Carolina | CS | Exercise | N/A | Vomiting or using laxatives, diet pills |
McVey et al. (2005) [20] | 1458 | 6th to 8th grade | 54 | 19 (M) 28 (P) |
38% Caucasian 26% South Asian 17% Asian-American 13% African-Canadian 14% Other |
Ontario, CA | CS | Exercise | Skipping meals | Vomiting, diet pills, laxatives or diuretics |
Page et al. (1993) [49] | 1915 | 10th to 12th grade | 51 | N/A | 73% Caucasian 25% African-American 2% Other |
Mississippi | CS | Exercise | Fasting, very restrictive diet, crash diet | Vomiting, diet pills, water pills, laxatives |
Phelps et al. (1993) [40] | 367f | 7th to 8th grade and 9th to 12th grade | 100 | N/A | N/A | New York | CS | N/A | N/A | Vomiting, diet pills, laxatives |
Rafiroiu et al. (2000) [43] | 1439 | 3rd to 5th grade | 52 | N/A | 55% Caucasian | South Carolina | CS | N/A | N/A | Vomiting, diet pills |
Serdula et al. (1993) [39] | 11,467 | 9th to 12th grade | 51 | 25 (P) | 55% Caucasian 20% African-American 20% Hispanic 6% Other |
USA‡ | CS | Exercise | Skipping meals | Vomiting, diet pills |
Shisslak et al. (1998) [48] | 523 | Elementary and middle school children | 100 | N/A | 48% Caucasian 26% Hispanic 17% Asian-American 5% African-American 2% Native-American 2% Other |
California, Arizona | CS | Exercise, eat less fat/sweets | Skipping meals, fasting | Vomiting, diet pills, laxatives |
Shisslak et al. (2006) [44] | 1164 | 6th to 9th grade | 100 | 19% overweight, 19% at risk overweight (M) | 43% Caucasian 40% Hispanic 17% African-American |
California, Arizona | CS | Exercise, cut back on food, eaten less sweets or fatty foods | Skipping meals, fasting | Vomiting, diet pills, laxatives |
Stevens et al. (1999) [41] | 304 | 4th grade | 54 | 12 (P) | 100% Native-American | Arizona, New Mexico, South Dakota | CS | Exercise, change what/how ate | Skipping meals, fasting | N/A |
Story et al. (1994) [47] | 13,454 | 7th to 12th grade | N/A | 31 (P) | 100% Native-American | South Dakota, New Mexico, Alaska, Minnesota, Montana, Tennessee, Utah, Arizona | CS | N/A | N/A | Vomiting, diet pills, laxatives, diuretics |
Story et al. (2001) [21] | 1441 | 2nd to 3rd grade | 48 | 42 (M) | 100% Native-American | Arizona, New Mexico, South Dakota | CS | Exercise, changed what/how much ate | Skipping meals, fasting | N/A |
Yost et al. (2010) [38] | 1040 | Females aged 13–18 | 100 | 15.5% overweight, 11.8% obese (as per BMI percentile) | 69% Caucasian 19% African-American 2% Native-American 3% Asian-American 12% Hispanic |
USA†† | CS | Exercise | N/A | N/A |
Zullig et al. (2006) [42] | 4175 | 9th to 12th grade | 54 | 54 (P) | 54% Caucasian 46% African-American |
South Carolina | CS | N/A | Fasting | Vomiting or laxatives, diet pills |
Note: ✝Sample reported here in terms found in the original article. Ethnicity reported here in the order found in the original article. aOW/OB overweight/obese, bM Measured OV/OB, cCS Cross-sectional, dL Longitudinal; eP self-perception OV/OB, fIn this study, students were assessed at three time points (1984, 1989 and 1992). Results from the most recent wave of the study (1992) are presented in this review. †Nationally representative sample: Add Health Wave I; ††Nationally representative sample: Add Health Wave I and II; ‡Nationally representative sample: Youth Risk Behavior Survey