Skip to main content
. 2018 Dec 5;13(12):e0207994. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0207994

Table 2. The quality assessment of included studies based on the Cochrane handbook.

Study A B C D E F G Total
Massie (1999) ? ? + ? + + + 4
Neill (2003) ? ? + + + + + 4
Mador (2005) + ? - ? + + + 4
Salgado (2008) ? ? - - + + + 3
Ryan (2009) ? ? + + + + + 4
Worsnop (2010) ? ? + + + - + 3
Ruhle(2011) ? ? ? ? + + + 3
Soudorn(2016) ? ? + ? + + + 4
Nilius(2016) ? ? + ? + + + 4

A = sequence generation; B = allocation concealment; C = blinding of participants and personnel; D = blinding of outcome assessment; E = incomplete outcome data; F = selective outcome reporting; G = other sources of bias; + = Yes;— = No; ? = unclear (‘Yes’ for a low risk of bias, ‘No’ for a high risk of bias; ‘Unclear’ otherwise)