Table 1.
Randomized Depression Interventions Involving Young, Black Males.
| Author | Intervention | Demographics | Outcomes | Did It Work? | Did It Work for Black Males? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Youth-centered behavioral treatment (four articles) | |||||
| Bittman, Dickson, and Coddington (2009) | HealthRHYTHMS | 12- to 18-year-old adolescents N = 30 females N = 22 males Includes African American |
Depression reduction | Yes; 6.1% reduction in depression total versus a depression within the conduction group 0.004 statistical significance |
Unknown; results are not reported based on race |
| Breland-Noble and AAKOMA Project Adult Advisory Board (2012) | AAKOMA Family Leadership Over Adolescent depression project | 11- to 17-year-old African American adolescents N = 5 males N = 11 females |
Depression treatment enrollment readiness | Yes; 100% effective in encouraging Black adolescents into depression treatment N = 5 versus 75% of delayed control group entered into depression treatment |
Unknown; Black male specifics not identified |
| Gunlicks-Stoessel, Mufson, Jekal, and Turner (2010) | Interpersonal psychotherapy for depressed adolescents | 12- to 18-year-old adolescents (14.3% Black) N = 53 females (84.1%) N = 10 males (15.9%) |
Depressive symptom reduction | Yes; for adolescents with high levels of conflict with mothers showed greater acceleration 0.35 effect size on baseline depression |
Unknown; Black male specifics not identified |
| McMullen, O’Callaghan, Shannon, Black, and Eakin (2013) | TF-CBT | 13- to 17-year-old former child soldiers (n = 39) and war-affected boys (n = 11) *Republic of the Congo |
Depressive symptom reduction | Yes; 31.1% reduction in depression and anxiety versus 8.9% reduction in control group 0.567 effect size on depression and anxiety |
Yes; 100% of the population were Black males |
| Youth-centered pharmacological/behavior treatment (one article) | |||||
| March and Vitiello (2009) | Treatment for adolescents with depression study | Specific demographics unreported in article, but notes minority representation Known as a universal intervention for all adolescents despite race |
Depressive symptom reduction | Yes; combination of CBT and fluoxetine works best with reducing depressive symptomology | Unknown; there was no indication of how many of the males were Black |
| Family-centered behavior treatment (four articles) | |||||
| Brody et al. (2012) | Strong African American Families–Teen | 502 Black families | Depressive symptom reduction | Yes; adolescents received a 12% reduction in depressive symptoms | Yes; 4% more effective for Black males than females |
| Compas et al. (2010) | Family group cognitive behavioral | 120 families with six (5%) Black | Depressive symptom reduction | Yes; depressive symptoms mediated through coping skills | Unknown; there was no indication of how many of the males were Black |
| Diamond, Reis, Diamond, Siqueland, and Isaacs (2002) | ABFT | 32 adolescents; 22% male; 69% Black adolescents | Depressive symptom reduction | Yes; 81% of patients in ABFT no longer major depressive disorder versus only 47% of those on the waitlist | Unknown; there was no indication of how many of the males were Black |
| Diamond et al. (2010) | ABFT | 11 males in the trial; 70% Black adolescents | Depressive symptom reduction | Yes; 0.97 effect size | Unknown; there was no indication of how many of the males were Black |
| Quality of depression treatment in primary care (two articles) | |||||
| Asarnow et al. (2009) | Quality improvement trial | 13- to 21-year-olds; 13% of total are Black adolescents; 22% of total are Black males | Depressive symptom reduction | Yes; 10% fewer of the treatment group had severe depression symptoms than the control group; only through 6 months There were no long-term effects within the treatment |
Unknown; treatment effect were not isolated |
| Ngo et al. (2009) | Youth partners in care | 13- to 21-year-old adolescents 18% of the 325 adolescents were Black |
Depression reduction | Yes; between 12% and 13% reduction in depression intervention for Black adolescents from usual care | Unknown; Black adolescents showed reduction, but Black males not specifically were not reported |
| Home environment treatment (one article) | |||||
| Leventhal and Brooks-Gunn (2003) | Moving to Opportunity for Fair Housing Demonstration | 11- to 15-year-old adolescents 49.9% of the families are African American 6.8% of male adolescents |
Depressive reduction | Yes; reduction in depressive symptoms | Unknown; males within the experimental groups reporting significantly less likely to suffer from depressive symptoms. Black male count is unknown. |
Note. TF-CBT = trauma-focused cognitive behavior therapy; ABFT = attachment-based family therapy.