Skip to main content
. 2018 Dec 11;16:1–11. doi: 10.1016/j.scog.2018.11.001

Table 2.

Childhood trauma and cognitive function in patients with established bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, psychosis and healthy participants.

Study Participants (Patients/Healthy participants)
N
Gender (Patients/Healthy participants)
Male : Female
Age (Patients/Healthy participants)
Mean/SD
Stress questionnaire Cognitive domains and tests Main findings – CT and cognitive performance
Patients with established bipolar disorder and healthy participants
Poletti et al., 2017 BD = 76
HP = 90
BD = 51 : 51
HP = 24 : 33
BD = 47.75 ± 11.58
HP = 29.60 ± 10.55
RFQ
  • BACS for verbal memory, working memory, psychomotor speed and coordination, selective attention, semantic fluency, letter fluency

  • WCST for executive functions

  • Significant effect of high levels of CT on poorer global cognitive ability across BD and HP groups

  • Significant effect of high levels of CT on poorer speed of processing in BD with opposite pattern in HP

Bucker et al., 2013 BP = 64
HP = 28
BP = 28 : 36
HP = 11 : 17
BP = 22.89 ± 4.36
HP = 22.78 ± 4.90
CTQ (28 – item version)
  • NART and Kaufman Brief Intelligence Test for intellectual ability

  • TMT, Stroop Test and Color Naming Trials for processing speed and executive function

  • CVLT for attention and verbal memory

  • WMS-III for working memory

  • CANTAB for attention, working memory, executive function and nonverbal memory

  • Poorer performance in memory for BP with CT in contrast to BP w/o CT

  • Poorer performance in memory for BP with CT in contrast to HP w/o CT

  • Significant negative correlation between greater number of CT events and poorer performance on memory in BP group

  • Significant negative associations between greater number of CT events and poorer performance on (i) executive functioning and (ii) memory in HP group

Marshall et al., 2016 BP = 233
HP = 90
BP w CT = 32 : 85
BP w/o CT = 42 : 74
HP w CT = 8 : 9
HP w/o CT = 28 : 45
BP w CT = 40.90 ± 11.40
BP w/o CT = 38.70 ± 13.10
HP w CT = 36.50 ± 14.20
HP w/o CT = 37.40 ± 14.10
CTQ (28 – item version)
  • WASI for general cognitive ability

  • Go/No-Go Task for attention and inhibitory control

  • Significant main effect of CT on executive function

  • Significantly negative correlation between present CT and reduced executive function in BP group




Patients with established schizophrenia and bipolar disorder
Aas et al., 2012b SZ = 239
BP = 167
SZ + BP = 214 : 192 SZ + BP = 30.07 ± 3.00 CTQ (28 – item version)
  • WASI for general cognitive function, perception, visuospatial abilities and verbal abilities

  • CVLT for verbal memory, verbal fluency and executive function

  • WMS-III for working memory

  • Significant relationships between PA, sexual abuse, physical neglect and poorer performance on general cognitive ability and executive function in BP group

  • No significant relationships between emotional neglect and general cognitive ability, memory and executive function




Patients with psychosis and healthy participants
van Os et al., 2017 PSY = 1119
(SZ = 940)
Siblings of PSYa = 1059
HP = 586
PSY = 850 : 269
Siblings of PSY1 = 487 : 572
HP = 270 : 316
PSY = 27.57 ± 7.95
Siblings of PSY1 = 27.83 ± 8.27
HP = 30.42 ± 10.58
CTQ (25-item version)
  • Baseline: WAIS-III for general cognitive functioning

  • 3 year follow-up: WAIS-III for general cognitive functioning

  • 6 year follow-up: WAIS-III short-form for general cognitive functioning

  • Negative association between higher scores of CT in HP and reduced general cognitive ability at 3 time points

  • No difference between groups for moderating effect of CT on time or general cognitive ability over 6 years




Patients with psychosis
Mansueto et al., 2017b PSY = 532 PSY = 402 : 130 PSY = 27.61 (7.61) CTQ (25-item version)
  • WAIS-III for general cognitive ability

  • World Learning Task for verbal memory

  • CTQ for attention and vigilance

  • RST for reasoning and working memory

  • PSY with CT performed worse on memory function than patients without CT.




Patients with established schizophrenia and healthy participants
Green et al., 2015 SZ = 617
HP = 659
SZ = 415 : 202
HP = 291 : 368
SZ = 39.65 ± 10.82
HP = 42.48 ± 13.58
CAQ (20-item version)
  • WTAR for premorbid IQ

  • RBANS for immediate memory, delayed memory, attention, language, construction

  • WAIS for working memory

  • COWAT for executive functioning

  • Significant main effect of childhood maltreatment and general cognitive ability for both SZ and HP groups separately.

Green et al., 2014 SZ = 617
HP = 659
SZ = 415 : 202
HP = 291 : 368
SZ = 39.65 ± 10.82
HP = 42.48 ± 13.58
CAQ (20-item version)
  • WTAR for premorbid IQ

  • RBANS for attention and memory function

  • WAIS for executive function

  • COWAT for executive function

  • Association between CT and cognitive performance not reported

McCabe et al., 2012 SZ = 408
HP = 267
SZ = 65.7 % male
HP = 43.4 % male
SZ = 40.72 ± 11.07
HP = 39.27 ± 13.70
CAQ (20 item version)
  • WTAR and WASI for general cognitive function

  • Negative associations between number of CT events and general cognitive ability across SZ and HP groups

  • In HP group only: Negative associations between number of CT events and general cognitive ability




Patients with established schizophrenia
Ruby et al., 2017 SZ = 28 SZ = 20 : 8 SZ = 31.50 (9.70) ETI
  • WAIS-III for general cognitive ability

  • WMS-R for verbal and visual memory, attention and delayed recall

  • WCST for executive function

  • TMT for processing speed and visual attention

  • COWAT for verbal fluency

  • No association between CT and cognitive function found

Li et al., 2017 SZ = 162 SZ = 58 : 104 SZ = 37.82 ± 10.16 CTQ (28 – item version)
  • RBANS for immediate memory, visuospatial construction, language, attention and delayed memory

  • Significant negative correlations between physical abuse, sexual abuse and CT with executive function.

  • Significant negative correlations between physical neglect with memory and executive function.

Kelly et al., 2016 SZ = 80 SZ = 56 : 24
Females with PA = 10
Females w/o PA = 14
Males with PA = 11
Males w/o PA = 45
Females with PA = 37.80 ± 10.80
Females w/o PA
= 32.60 ± 11.90
Males with PA = 30.90 ± 7.70
Males w/o PA = 31.6 ± 9.80
CTQ (28-item version)
  • RBANS for immediate memory, delayed memory, visuo-spatial construction, language and attention

  • No significant differences for general cognitive ability and memory between the groups

Shannon et al., 2011 SZ = 85 SZ = 67 : 18 SZ = 41.10 ± 11.70 CTQ (28-item version)
  • NART for premorbid IQ

  • WMS-III for verbal memory, working memory

  • SZ with CT performed better on general cognitive ability than SZ w/o CT

  • SZ with CT performed worse on memory than SZ w/o CT

  • SZ with CT performed better on working memory than SZ w/o CT

Schenkel et al., 2005 SZ SZ = 40 SZ = 25 : 15
SZ with ACE = 10 : 8
SZ w/o ACE = 15 : 7
SZ = 41.90 ± 10.70 Medical charts and interview
  • Shipley Institute of Living Scale Vocabulary Subtest for verbal intelligence

  • Hayling Sentence Completion Task for verbal processing speed and verbal inhibition

  • Brixton Spatial Anticipation Task for non-verbal problem-solving and sequencing skills

  • COWAT for verbal fluency

  • Contour Integration Test for visual context processing

  • SZ with a history of abuse performed worse than SZ w/o a history of abuse on general cognitive ability

  • No significant correlations between history of abuse and executive function

  • In a factor analysis of hospitalizations, cognitive domains, childhood problems and clinical symptoms-childhood problems and greater clinical symptomatology with cognitive impairment were significant

  • Significant effect across groups for the association between reduced general cognitive ability with greater exposure to abuse

Lysaker et al., 2002 SZ = 36 SZ = 36 : 0 SZ = 46.00 ± 10.00 CAQ
  • WAIS-III for premorbid intelligence and working memory

  • No findings reported for relationships between trauma, general cognitive ability and executive function

Abbreviations: BACS, Brief Assessment of Cognition in Schizophrenia; BD, patients with bipolar disorder; CANTAB, Cambridge Neuropsychological Automated Test Battery; CATS, The Child Abuse and Trauma Scale, CAQ, Childhood Adversity Questionnaire; COWAT, Controlled Oral Word Association Test; CT, Childhood trauma; CTQ, Childhood Trauma Questionnaire; CVLT, California Verbal Learning Test; ETI, Early Trauma Inventory; HP, healthy participants; IQ, intelligence quotient; NART, National Adult Reading Test; PSY, patients with psychosis; RBANS, Repeated Battery for Assessment of Neuropsychological Status; RFQ, Risky Families Questionnaire; RST, Response Shifting Task; SD, Standard Deviation; SZ, Patients with schizophrenia; TMT, Trail Making Task; WASI, Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence; WAIS-III, Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale - III; WCST, Wisconsin Card Sorting Test; WSM-III, Wechsler Memory Scale; WTAR, Wechsler Test of Adult Reading.

a

No psychiatric diagnosis.

b

Only baseline data reported.