Table 1. Relative optical density (ROD) of artificial enamel lesions treated with rGO/AG, GO and AgNPs at different depths of tooth specimens (n=10).
Caries depth | Negative Control | 0.08 mg/mL rGO/Ag | 0.12 mg/mL rGO/Ag | 0.16 mg/mL rGO/Ag | 0.16 mg/mL rGO | 0.16 mg/mL AgNPs | 10 ppm NaF |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
10 μm | 74.44±3.35c | 76.58±3.30bc | 77.06±1.66bc | 76.93±3.47bc | 79.73±6.16b | 79.69±7.54b | 94.64±3.87a |
30 μm | 72.89±2.73c | 74.80±3.49bc | 75.43±2.90bc | 74.81±3.85bc | 76.33±3.41b | 76.87±3.98b | 97.99±2.34a |
50 μm | 73.53±2.28c | 74.32±2.81c | 75.59±3.18bc | 77.47±5.08b | 75.46±3.54bc | 75.86±3.68bc | 98.84±2.26a |
70 μm | 73.92±2.04c | 75.33±3.29bc | 76.94±4.74bc | 78.30±5.17b | 75.71±3.24bc | 76.40±4.51bc | 99.60±0.79a |
90 μm | 75.35±3.49c | 75.51±3.65c | 78.76±6.18bc | 82.04±6.19b | 75.61±3.62c | 80.59±5.65b | 99.50±0.85a |
110 μm | 75.51±3.71d | 77.11±3.85d | 82.41±3.85c | 93.40±3.86b | 75.57±3.78d | 83.69±3.63c | 99.89±0.55a |
130 μm | 76.31±4.45c | 75.59±3.84d | 83.50±3.47b | 99.20±1.20a | 75.79±3.84c | 86.42±5.01b | 99.91±0.37a |
150 μm | 78.82±4.07b | 84.48±3.61bc | 85.90±3.26c | 99.64±0.64a | 77.07±3.58b | 94.37±5.08ac | 99.98±0.21a |
170 μm | 86.18±9.82b | 90.73±7.46bc | 95.20±5.97cd | 99.81±0.39ac | 81.40±10.78b | 99.82±0.33ac | 100.00±0.20ad |
190 μm | 90.20±8.55b | 97.91±2.38bc | 98.85±1.35c | 99.87±0.28ac | 86.37±11.08b | 100.00±0.06ac | 99.95±0.20ac |
210 μm | 92.55±8.94b | 99.51±0.66bcd | 99.87±0.31ac | 99.98±0.12ac | 90.81±9.64bc | 100.00±0.09ad | 99.98±0.14ac |
230 μm | 96.25±5.08a | 100.00±0.06bc | 100.00±0.07bc | 99.89±0.25ac | 97.47±2.30ac | 100.00±0.07bc | 99.90±0.25ac |
ROD was calculated as ODR=ODl/ODs × 100%; ODl represents the OD of the enamel demineralized layer, ODs represents the OD of the sound enamel tissue (blank control) measured at the corresponding tooth specimen level. Values annotated with different superscripts (a–d) within the same row indicate statistically significant differences (p<0.05) between different groups