Table 4. Outcomes and summary of findings from the included studies.
Study author & year | Outcome measures | Time points | Intervention(s) and comparator | Significance of outcomes between-groups | Significance of outcomes within-groups |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Henderson et al. (2007) | Anxiety: STAI | Pre- and post-treatment and follow-up (1 month later) | Experimental group (trauma-related mandala design; n = 19) vs control group (object drawing; n = 17) |
Anxiety: NS | Exp. group: Anxiety: NS Control group: Anxiety (STAI): NS |
Sandmire et al. (2012) | Anxiety: STAI | Pre- and post-art-making (no follow-up) | Experimental group (art-making; n = 29) vs control group (sitting; n = 28) | Anxiety (state): S** Anxiety (trait):S* | Exp. group: Anxiety (state): S** Anxiety (trait) S** Control group (inactive): Anxiety (state): NS Anxiety (trait): NS |
Zhan Yu et al. (2016) | Anxiety: HAM-A SAS | Pre- and post-treatment (no follow-up) | Experimental group (HTP followed by group interview; n = 33) vs control group (only group interview; n = 36) |
NR | Exp. group: HAM-A:S*** SAS:S** Control group: HAM-A: NS SAS:S* (higher anxiety score) |
NR = Not reported.
NS = Not significant.
S = Significant
* = p<0.05.
** = p<0.01.
*** = p<0.001.
STAI: Spielberger's State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (self-report); HAM-A: Hamilton Anxiety Scale; SAS: Zung Self-Rating Anxiety Scale.