TABLE 1.
Technology | LOD (CFU/ml)a | Sensitivity (%)b | Specificity (%)b | TATc | Price/sample ($) | References |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Molecular genetics | 102–2 × 104 | 96–99 | 96–99 | 1–3 h | 5–50d | 21–23 |
Biochemical methods | 6 × 108 | 90–99 | 96–100 | 30 min–2 h | 1–5e | 24–29 |
Immunoassays | 104–106 | 96–100 | 97–100 | 20 min | 7–15f | 30–33 |
Electrochemical assays | 106–109 | 95–96 | 100 | 5–30 min | 1 (plus $100 for the homemade reader)g |
34–36 |
MALDI-TOF MS | 105–106 | 98–100 | 92–100 | 30 min–3 h | 1–10 | 44, 53–55, 60–66, 132 |
LOD, limit of detection, expressed in CFU per milliliter, of the different technologies.
Ranges of sensitivity and specificity of the different technologies.
TAT, turnaround time of the different technologies.
The price is lower if performing in-house methods and maximum if using commercial kits.
The price is lower if performing in-house methods and maximum if using the Rapidec Carba NP system (bioMérieux).
The price increases if resistance detection is focused on more than one cassette. The prices for OXA-48 K-SeT and KPC K-SeT are around $7/sample, the price for O.K.N. K-SeT is around $14/sample (detection of OXA-48, KPC, and NDM in the same test), and the price for O.K.N.V. K-SeT is around $15/sample (detection of OXA-48, KPC, NDM, and VIM in the same test).
The price is around $1/sample, the electrodes are made in-house and cost around $2/electrode, and the reader is also produced in-house, at about $100.