Table 1. Search strategy and study selection criteria.
Search Strategy | ||
PubMed Search Strategy | ((policy[Title/Abstract] OR policies[Title/Abstract] OR prevention[Title/Abstract] OR "primary prevention"[Mesh]) AND ("Child, Preschool"[Mesh] OR "Infant"[Mesh] OR childhood[Ti] OR childcare[Ti] OR early childhood[Ti] OR preschool[Ti]) AND (obesity[mh] OR obese[tiab] OR obesity[tiab] OR overweight[tiab] OR over-weight[tiab])) NOT (("Review"[Publication Type] OR "Meta-Analysis"[Publication Type] OR "Meeting Abstracts"[Publication Type] OR "research design"[Mesh])) | |
Limits | Full text; Publication date from 2001/01/01; Humans; English; Newborn: birth-1 month; Infant: birth-23 months; Infant: 1–23 months; Preschool Child: 2–5 years | |
Study Selection Criteria (PICOTS) | ||
Inclusion Criteria | Exclusion Criteria | |
Population | -Children under the age of 6 - Records/ separate analysis of children under the age of 6, if older children were also included -Otherwise healthy |
-Populations of exclusively obese or overweight children -Children with a chronic illness, disability, congenital malformation or significant medical condition that could contribute to changes in body weight |
Interventions, Policies or Practices | Any intervention, program or policy aimed at preventing early childhood obesity | -Interventions, programs or policies aimed at obesity treatment or promoting weight loss |
Comparison | -Other intervention, programs or policy aimed at preventing early childhood obesity -Or usual care, within the same aged children and in a similar setting -Or an equivalent historical control group or policy period |
-No relevant comparator group |
Outcome | Change in a weight-based measure of growth or weight status such as weight, weight/weight percentiles, BMI / BMIz-score, or BMI categories (underweight, normal weight, overweight, obese) compared to a comparator group | -No weight-based outcome measure |
Timing | -Interventions/programs lasting at least 6 months long or collecting a weight-based outcome measure 6 months after initiation -Policies since 2001 |
- Interventions/programs less than 6 months |
Setting |
-Individual (primary-care based) -Interpersonal (home-based, peers) -Community (childcare-based, community organizations) -Societal (policies, health information, social norms) |
-Non-US settings or policies |
Year Range | Publications from Jan 2001 to Feb 2018 | -Publication prior to 2001 |
Studies estimating implementation costs, cost effectiveness analyses and policy studies were included provided that the assumptions and datasets included children under 6 years of age. |