Table 5.
AUC obtained by RF on 15 ADE datasets: 4 methods are compared, respectively sl, plain, mc and lr
0.2 | 0.3 | 0.5 | 0.7 | 0.9 | 0.95 | 1.0 | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
D61.1 | plain | 78.151 | 80.842 | 80.817 | 80.909 | 84.107 | 84.801 | 82.484 |
mc | 76.876 | 78.132 | 80.163 | 78.854 | 81.259 | 82.946 | 81.720 | |
lr | 77.978 | 80.720 | 79.961 | 79.675 | 83.624 | 83.610 | 81.510 | |
sl | 73.846 | 78.653 | 78.928 | 80.756 | 83.016 | 82.412 | 82.817 | |
E27.3 | plain | 51.916 | 58.345 | 56.302 | 59.870 | 58.882 | 62.518 | 66.854 |
mc | 48.953 | 50.052 | 46.695 | 50.126 | 61.773 | 59.444 | 58.854 | |
lr | 58.445 | 58.637 | 56.816 | 61.179 | 59.170 | 64.162 | 67.266 | |
sl | 60.763 | 62.054 | 59.670 | 58.718 | 58.035 | 64.686 | 66.500 | |
G62.0 | plain | 64.443 | 71.325 | 75.452 | 77.247 | 78.839 | 79.074 | 80.279 |
mc | 66.228 | 72.700 | 71.376 | 76.974 | 74.769 | 74.146 | 74.713 | |
lr | 64.713 | 70.756 | 74.787 | 77.169 | 78.992 | 79.357 | 79.418 | |
sl | 61.473 | 69.429 | 76.335 | 78.379 | 81.980 | 81.509 | 82.222 | |
I95.2 | plain | 56.157 | 57.338 | 54.871 | 52.257 | 54.046 | 59.855 | 56.369 |
mc | 57.486 | 57.390 | 54.750 | 49.333 | 53.480 | 51.742 | 57.391 | |
lr | 58.052 | 54.797 | 58.165 | 53.184 | 56.145 | 57.145 | 56.362 | |
sl | 47.671 | 49.289 | 51.080 | 51.509 | 53.065 | 54.267 | 53.943 | |
L27.0 | plain | 60.374 | 68.063 | 66.689 | 67.815 | 65.273 | 67.416 | 65.322 |
mc | 56.065 | 62.683 | 66.766 | 65.527 | 67.431 | 66.443 | 64.500 | |
lr | 56.585 | 66.422 | 66.256 | 67.020 | 66.277 | 68.424 | 66.110 | |
sl | 55.400 | 62.981 | 61.919 | 64.648 | 64.597 | 65.136 | 68.271 | |
L27.1 | plain | 58.130 | 61.600 | 63.471 | 64.835 | 63.012 | 62.454 | 61.798 |
mc | 56.093 | 55.029 | 67.179 | 61.970 | 64.556 | 61.222 | 62.455 | |
lr | 58.636 | 64.100 | 65.983 | 66.264 | 67.196 | 63.884 | 64.012 | |
sl | 53.709 | 61.418 | 62.955 | 66.461 | 66.554 | 67.397 | 67.316 | |
M80.4 | plain | 55.646 | 54.745 | 59.375 | 59.029 | 68.713 | 67.004 | 65.396 |
mc | 55.729 | 55.770 | 52.641 | 58.996 | 66.863 | 63.000 | 63.507 | |
lr | 55.753 | 58.056 | 58.849 | 59.760 | 68.912 | 69.119 | 67.756 | |
sl | 47.933 | 57.149 | 52.678 | 58.414 | 67.945 | 65.199 | 64.845 | |
O35.5 | plain | 51.650 | 52.557 | 64.963 | 73.161 | 77.383 | 78.590 | 80.298 |
mc | 52.741 | 52.962 | 55.361 | 68.843 | 70.114 | 72.079 | 70.104 | |
lr | 52.756 | 53.551 | 68.318 | 76.971 | 78.332 | 80.322 | 81.324 | |
sl | 52.401 | 52.188 | 67.201 | 73.696 | 75.025 | 78.140 | 79.142 | |
T78.2 | plain | 53.028 | 51.573 | 56.977 | 56.538 | 57.153 | 58.709 | 59.229 |
mc | 55.811 | 54.349 | 53.146 | 55.771 | 53.260 | 54.417 | 53.092 | |
lr | 52.924 | 52.369 | 55.286 | 59.569 | 63.066 | 57.775 | 59.254 | |
sl | 53.113 | 50.471 | 50.492 | 57.561 | 56.850 | 58.646 | 59.421 | |
T78.3 | plain | 51.177 | 54.073 | 52.614 | 54.575 | 58.973 | 59.449 | 63.647 |
mc | 48.308 | 50.692 | 51.378 | 53.746 | 56.715 | 55.334 | 58.111 | |
lr | 51.762 | 53.238 | 55.155 | 56.952 | 59.213 | 61.924 | 66.209 | |
sl | 50.514 | 51.851 | 54.273 | 53.531 | 56.337 | 59.759 | 64.728 | |
T78.4 | plain | 51.937 | 54.675 | 58.151 | 56.976 | 57.124 | 56.506 | 59.162 |
mc | 52.176 | 55.459 | 55.644 | 54.720 | 53.475 | 55.145 | 56.218 | |
lr | 54.434 | 58.122 | 54.655 | 57.019 | 56.627 | 58.496 | 58.549 | |
sl | 49.903 | 49.876 | 47.081 | 50.235 | 54.326 | 56.986 | 58.444 | |
T80.1 | plain | 78.962 | 77.270 | 84.589 | 83.097 | 86.832 | 85.994 | 84.189 |
mc | 73.207 | 72.912 | 73.492 | 78.945 | 74.963 | 79.334 | 74.592 | |
lr | 78.930 | 80.478 | 83.233 | 83.739 | 84.677 | 84.879 | 85.803 | |
sl | 75.125 | 76.542 | 79.956 | 81.759 | 81.413 | 83.918 | 82.726 | |
T80.8 | plain | 80.744 | 81.769 | 83.486 | 83.704 | 85.648 | 86.136 | 86.751 |
mc | 71.968 | 71.717 | 76.488 | 77.570 | 78.308 | 78.182 | 80.725 | |
lr | 81.119 | 81.211 | 85.431 | 85.210 | 86.319 | 86.715 | 86.627 | |
sl | 80.537 | 80.973 | 84.689 | 85.569 | 86.332 | 86.875 | 87.351 | |
T88.6 | plain | 61.998 | 60.731 | 62.299 | 62.830 | 65.113 | 63.499 | 62.249 |
mc | 58.342 | 58.993 | 63.476 | 57.263 | 59.652 | 59.568 | 61.812 | |
lr | 60.283 | 60.159 | 62.019 | 63.256 | 60.864 | 61.744 | 64.120 | |
sl | 57.623 | 57.248 | 57.450 | 57.417 | 58.190 | 57.672 | 60.403 | |
T88.7 | plain | 58.971 | 60.742 | 62.399 | 62.239 | 62.552 | 63.803 | 65.352 |
mc | 56.875 | 57.931 | 62.472 | 60.892 | 63.013 | 62.435 | 64.209 | |
lr | 60.580 | 60.462 | 62.803 | 61.543 | 62.588 | 64.137 | 66.276 | |
sl | 60.297 | 59.862 | 61.498 | 61.811 | 62.259 | 64.001 | 65.139 |
For each ADE, several sparsity threshold are considered, from 0.2 up to 1.0. The AUC reported for each combination is averaged by cross-validation on 10 different dataset splits. The best result is bold, and the highest AUC for each threshold underlined