Table 1. Criteria used to judge the level of evidence and establish the class of recommendation for AHF.
| Class | Class I | Class IIa | Class IIb | Class III | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Criterion | • Benefit >>> Risk | • Benefit >> Risk | • Benefit ≥ Risk | • No benefit or harm | |
| • Procedure/Treatment SHOULD be performed | • Additional studies with focused objectives are needed | • Additional studies with broad objectives are needed; collecting additional registry data would be helpful | • Procedure/treatment SHOULD NOT BE PERFORMED as it is not expected to be useful or may even be harmful | ||
| • IT IS REASONABLE to perform the procedure/treatment | • Procedure/treatment MAY BE CONSIDERED | ||||
| Level A | |||||
| • Multiple populations evaluated | 1) Recommendation that procedure/treatment is useful/effective | 1) Recommendation in favor of procedure or treatment being useful/effective | 1) Recommendation's usefulness/efficacy less well-established | 1) Recommendation that procedure/treatment is not useful/effective and/or may be harmful | |
| • Data from multiple randomized clinical trials or meta-analyses | 2) Sufficient evidence from multiple randomized trials or meta-analyses | 2) Some conflicting evidence from multiple randomized trials or meta-analyses | 2) Greater conflicting evidence from multiple randomized trials or meta-analyses | 2) Evidence from multiple randomized trials or meta-analyses | |
| Level B | |||||
| • Limited populations evaluated | 1) Recommendation that procedure/treatment is useful/effective | 1) Recommendation in favor of procedure/treatment being useful/effective | 1) Recommendation's usefulness/efficacy less well-established | 1) Recommendation that procedure/treatment is not useful/effective or may be harmful | |
| • Data from a single randomized trial or non-randomized studies | 2) Sufficient evidence from a single randomized trial or non-randomized studies | 2) Some conflicting evidence from a single randomized trial or non-randomized studies | 2) Greater conflicting evidence from a single randomized trial or non-randomized studies | 2) Evidence from a single randomized trial or non-randomized studies | |
| Level C | |||||
| • Very limited populations evaluated | 1) Recommendation that procedure/treatment is useful/effective | 1) Recommendation in favor of procedure/treatment being useful/effective | 1) Recommendation's usefulness/efficacy less well established | 1) Recommendation that procedure or treatment is not useful/effective and may be harmful | |
| • Only consensus expert opinions, case studies, or standards of care | 2) Only expert opinions, case studies, or standards of care | 2) Only diverging expert opinions, case studies, or standards of care | 2) Only diverging expert opinions, case studies, or standards of care | 2) Only expert opinions, case studies, or standards of care | |
AHF = acute heart failure.