Skip to main content
. 2019 Jan 8;9:1947. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2018.01947

Table 1.

Linear mixed-effect model results for the effects of temperature and species on the plant growth and sediment pore water nutrient parameters, plant traits and RCR.

Category Parameters Factors df F p Means comparison among species
Plant growth Shoot biomass Temperature 1, 13 211.93 <0.001 P. lucens > V. spiralis = E. nuttallii
Species 2, 110 82.45 <0.001
Temp.* Species 2, 110 43.68 <0.001
Root biomass Temperature 1, 13 56.99 <0.001 P. lucens = V. spiralis > E. nuttallii
Species 2, 110 131.39 <0.001
Temp.* Species 2, 110 20.87 <0.001
Growth rate Temperature 1, 13 43.45 <0.001 P. lucens > V. spiralis > E. nuttallii
Species 2, 110 429.65 <0.001
Temp.* Species 2, 110 8.47 <0.001
Root:Shoot ratio Temperature 1, 13 4.54 0.053 V. spiralis > P. lucens > E. nuttallii
Species 2, 110 419.52 <0.001
Temp.* Species 2, 110 23.27 <0.001
Porewater nutrients TINa Temperature 1, 13 3.68 0.077 E. nuttallii > P. lucens = V. spiralis
Species 2, 26 12.62 <0.001
Temp.* Species 2, 26 2.05 0.149
PO43- Temperature 1, 13 16.76 0.001 E. nuttallii > P. lucens = V. spiralis
Species 2, 26 8.78 0.001
Temp.* Species 2, 26 3.17 0.059
Palatability RCRb Temperature 1, 13 4.01 0.067 P. lucens = V. spiralis > E. nuttallii
Species 2, 112 8.42 <0.001
Traits Dry matter content Temperature 1, 13 2.15 0.166 P. lucens > E. nuttallii > V. spiralis
Species 2, 110 448.82 <0.001
Temp.* Species 2, 110 8.80 <0.001
C content Temperature 1, 13 0.83 0.378 P. lucens > E. nuttallii = V. spiralis
Species 2, 110 67.57 <0.001
Temp.* Species 2, 110 16.70 <0.001
N content Temperature 1, 13 5.57 0.035 E. nuttallii > P. lucens > V. spiralis
Species 2, 110 17.51 <0.001
Temp.* Species 2, 110 6.85 0.002
P content Temperature 1, 13 4.82 0.047 V. spiralis > E. nuttallii > P. lucens
Species 2, 110 58.84 <0.001
Temp.* Species 2, 110 17.33 <0.001
C:N ratio Temperature 1, 13 3.02 0.106 P. lucens = V. spiralis > E. nuttallii
Species 2, 110 9.37 <0.001
Temp.* Species 2, 110 4.32 0.016
C:P ratio Temperature 1, 13 7.14 0.019 P. lucens > E. nuttallii > V. spiralis
Species 2, 110 68.50 <0.001
Temp.* Species 2, 110 18.88 <0.001
N:P ratio Temperature 1, 13 0.99 0.338 P. lucens > E. nuttallii > V. spiralis
Species 2, 110 116.01 <0.001
Temp.* Species 2, 110 14.64 <0.001
Total phenolics content Temperature 1, 13 1.55 0.235 P. lucens > E. nuttallii = V. spiralis
Species 2, 110 318.23 <0.001
Temp.* Species 2, 110 9.23 <0.001
N:Phenolics ratio Temperature 1, 13 4.13 0.063 E. nuttallii = V. spiralis > P. lucens
Species 2, 110 69.74 <0.001
Temp.* Species 2, 110 6.51 0.002

Means comparison among species was done by a Tukey post-hoc test after each linear mixed-effect model test. Temp. indicates the factor temperature.

a

TIN means total dissolved inorganic nitrogen.

b

RCR means plant relative consumption rate. Bold numbers indicate a significance of p < 0.05.