Skip to main content
. 2019 Jan 17;14(1):e0210761. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0210761

Table 4. Intervention characteristics.

No. 1st Author Intervention Description Nature of human-animal interaction Theoretical underpinnings Format Setting Dose
1 Hamama, L. • I = Goal-focused canine-related activities such as building trust, training, talking to or walking the canines
• C = psychosocial topics such as trust and confidence building exercises
• Brief program outline & session examples provided
Structured and semi-structured interactions To increase trust and socialisation via the presence of animals, and to facilitate role changes via canine-related activities. Group Secondary School setting
• I = classroom & local park
• C = classroom
3 hours once per week for 12 weeks. Total hours = 36
2 Hanselman, J. L. • I = Anger management group incorporating creative and projective activities, a Scared Straight night, and discussions while canines were present
• Detailed intervention goals provided.
• No program/session outlines provided
Spontaneous Cognitive Behavioural Therapy; Attachment Theory; To lower client arousal and anger via the presence of animals Group Not described 10 sessions over 12 weeks
3 Hartwig, E. • HART model intervention with (I) or without(C) canines. Integrates creative and expressive techniques into therapy. Standardised intervention to be applied by multiple therapists.
• Example activities provided.
Structured interactions Solution Focused Therapy; Play therapy; To improve engagement and motivation via the presence of an animal Individual Community counselling service (small indoor counselling rooms) 50-minute sessions weekly for 10 sessions. Total hours = 8.3 (Plus caregiver consults)
4 Lange, A. M. • I = Anger management group incorporating pre-determined goal-focussed activities with the canine, and information about the care and keeping of an animal
• No program/session outlines provided
Structured and spontaneous interactions That the presence of an animal may provide benefits to the participants based on previous research Group Not described Not described
5 Lubbe, C. • I = individual counselling with a canine, therapeutic goals identified
• No program/session outlines provided.
Structured, semi-structured and spontaneous interactions That the presence of the animal may assist with engagement and rapport as previous therapy had not been successful Individual Counselling service indoors Not described
6 Stefanini, 2015 • I = Hospital TAU plus structured goal-focussed sessions incorporating a canine, engaging in a range of activities such as play, physical contact, grooming, cleaning, basic obedience, walking and agility
• C = Hospital TAU
• Brief example session activities provided.
Structured and semi-structured To build the evidence base that AAT may assist with the treatment of psychiatric illness. Individual & group Psychiatric Hospital activity room (indoors) and garden (outdoors) 45-minute sessions weekly for 3 months. Total hours = 9
7 Stefanini, 2016 • I = Hospital TAU plus structured goal-focussed sessions incorporating a canine, engaging in a range of activities such as play, physical contact, grooming, cleaning, basic obedience, walking and agility
• C = Hospital TAU
• Brief example session activities provided.
Structured and semi-structured To incorporate an animal in TAU to enhance trust, improve therapeutic alliance & therapeutic process Familiarisation & matching; 5 individual and 5 group sessions Psychiatric Hospital activity room (indoors) and garden (outdoors) 45-minute sessions weekly for 3 months. Total hours = 9

I = intervention group or experimental group, C = control or comparison group; TAU = Treatment as Usual