Table 3.
Description of studies using a Helicobacter pylori test and treat strategy to reduce upper gastrointestinal endoscopies
Study | Country | Sample | Strategy | No endoscopy after HP test and treat |
Hu et al[43], 2006 | China | 161 patients | UGIE vs HP testing (UBT) + eradication (HP+) or Cisapride (HP-). | Symptom relief: 44%. Endoscopy for all after 6 weeks. |
Mahadeva et al[44], 2008 | Malaysia | 432 patients | UGIE vs HP testing (UBT) + eradication (HP+) or reassurance and/or empirical treatment (HP-) | 89% |
Arents et al[45], 2003 | Netherlands | 270 patients | UGIE vs HP testing (serology) + eradication (HP+) or Cisapride (HP-) | 68% |
Laheij et al[46], 2004 | Netherlands | 199 patients | UGIE vs omeprazole 2 wk followed by UGIE (no improvement) or HP serology testing (relapse) + eradication (HP+) | 94% |
Duggan et al[47], 2008 | United Kingdom | 584 patients | UGIE vs HP test + endoscopy (HP+) vs HP testing (serology) + eradication and/or endoscopy (HP+) or Lanzoprazole (HP-). | 73% |
Heaney et al[49], 1999 | United Kingdom | 104 patients | All received HP testing (UBT). Randomization of HP+ patients: UGIE or eradication therapy. | 73% |
McColl et al[50], 2002 | United Kingdom | 708 patients | UGIE vs HP testing (UBT) + eradication (HP+). | 92% |
Lassen et al[51], 2000 | Denmark | 500 patients | UGIE vs HP testing (UBT) + eradication (HP+), PPI (HP-, NSAID-, reflux+), or lifestyle advice (HP-, NSAID-, reflux-) | 60% |
Fraser et al[48], 2003 | New Zealand | 173 patients | All received UBT and eradication if HP+ | 76% |
Slade et al[53], 1999 | United Kingdom | 232 patients | All received HP serology testing + UGIE (HP equivocal), eradication (HP+), or usual care (HP-). | 73% |
Patel et al[54], 1995 | United Kingdom | 183 patients | All received serology testing + UGIE for HP+, sinister symptoms, or NSAID use. | 37% (after HP-) |
UGIE: Upper gastrointestinal endoscopy; HP: Helicobacter pylori; UBT: Urea breath test, NSAID: Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs.