Table 3.
Kidney care–specific elements based on WHO UHC domainsa and relevant data sources
Building blocks | Indicators/metrics | Data sources | Essential elements |
---|---|---|---|
Health service delivery | Number of health facilities for general CKD care RRT services (e.g., number of health facilities offering HD services per country) Public and private Nondialysis CKD care structure RRT care structure |
Literature reviews Surveys Interviews |
Accessibility of dialysis and kidney transplant units to all within the countries Access to medications Reimbursement of treatment and care Kidney transplant wait list Access to psychosocial counseling and support Existence of patient organizations in each country to facilitate advocacy |
Health work force | No. of nephrologists (per million population) No. of general physicians (per million population) No. of community health workers (per million population) No. of nurses (per million population) Regional distribution Nephrology trainees/graduates per year Availability of MDT |
Literature reviews Surveys Interviews WHO Global Observatory |
Professionals (GPs, nephrologists, diabetologists, endocrinologists, cardiologists, other related disciplines): total and as a ratio to whole population/ or dialysis population Financial resources, remuneration and incentives (including those for GPs/specialists to identify and manage CKD patients) Presence of other credentialed health care providers (e.g., nephrology nurses, dietitians) |
Health information systems | CKD (nondialysis) registry RRT registry |
Literature reviews Surveys Interviews |
Reach Scope |
Essential medicines and technologies | ACEIs/ARBs Statins Aspirin Other BP medications Anemia meds (Epo/iron) CKD-MBD (calcium binders, renagel, cinacalcet) Specific (GN and transplant) Dialysis availability, access, and coverage Transplant availability, access, and coverage |
Literature reviews Surveys Interviews WHO Global Observatory (for some essential medicines) |
|
Health financing | Total expenditure on health for CKD Public + private contributions Out-of-pocket payments for essential medicines Out-of-pocket payments for nondialysis CKD care Out-of-pocket payments for dialysis Out-of-pocket payments for transplant |
Literature reviews Surveys Interviews WHO Global Observatory |
|
Leadership and governance (national policies and frameworks) |
Guidelines/frameworks on CKD care Advocacy efforts and initiatives Early detection and prevention programs eGFR reporting |
Literature reviews Surveys Interviews WHO Global Observatory WHO NCD Strategy |
ACEIs/ARBs, angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors/angiotensin receptor blockers; BP, blood pressure; CKD, chronic kidney disease; eGFR, estimated glomerular filtration rate; Epo, erythropoietin; GN, glomerulonephritis; GPs, general practitioners; HD, hemodialysis; MDT, multidisciplinary team; MBD; mineral bone disorder; NCD, noncommunicable disease; RRT, renal replacement therapy; UHC, universal health care.
WHO UHC domains (service delivery, health work force, information systems, medicines and medical products, financing, and leadership).