Table 1C.
Study | Food allergen | N | Age Range | Study design | Maintenance Dose | Desensitization Outcome | Long-term results | Adverse events |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Staden et al. 200773 | Lyophilized egg white. | 45 (11 egg, 10 egg avoidance control, 24 other foods) | 0.6–12 years. | RCT, open-label (OIT/egg-free diet). | 1600 mg egg daily plus deliberate intake | 64% (16/25) fully or partially desensitized (milk and egg OIT assessed jointly), 35% of control later tolerant. | 36% of egg OIT had sustained tolerance (passed DBPCFC after stopping OIT for 2 months) vs. 35% of controls. | All OIT patients had some symptoms; 20% (4/20) of control had symptoms with accidental ingestion. |
Buchanan et al. 200774 Burks et al. 200875 |
Dried egg white. | 21 (initially 7) | 1–16 years. | Open-label, no control. | 300 mg daily | 90% of 21 reached 300 mg daily, 57% of 7 initial patients passed DBPCFC for 8 g egg. | 26% of 7 had sustained unresponsiveness (pass DBPCFC after stopping OIT 3–4 months). | Up-dosing: 1/7 initial patients reacted. Maintenance: no reactions in 7/7 patients, 3 did not react to accidental egg exposure. |
Vickery et al. 201076 | Dried egg white. | 8 | 3–13 years. | Open-label, no control (same protocol as,32 different patients). | 300 mg–3.6 g daily | 75% (6/8) OIT reached maintenance. After 4 months, 62.5 % (5/5 tested) passed OFC to 3.9 g egg, 1 not tested. After median 34 months, 75% (6/6 who reached maintenance) passed DBPCFC. | Sustained unresponsiveness: After 1 month off OIT, 75% (6/6) passed 2nd DBPCFC. All incorporated egg into the diet. | Buildup:4/6 who completed had reactions. Maintenance: no reactions. No reactions requiring epinephrine. |
Burks et al. 201217 | Dried egg white. | 55 | 5–11 years. | RCT, placebo-controlled, double-blind (OIT/placebo). | 2 g daily (approx 1/3 egg) | At 10 months, 55% on OIT, 0% on placebo desensitized (OFC 5 g). At 22 months, 75% on OIT desensitized (OFC 10 g). | Sustained unresponsiveness: at 24 months, after off egg for 4–6 weeks, 27.5% OIT passed 10 g OFC. Not tested in placebo. | Desensitization: adverse events with 25% of 11,680 OIT doses, 4 % 4018 placebo doses. No adverse events in patients with SU consuming egg ad lib. |
Fuentes-Aparicio et al. 2013 57 | Dried egg white. | 72 | 5–15 years. | RCT, open-label (OIT/egg-free diet). | 10 g daily | After 1 month: 92% (37/40) OIT, 22% (7/32) control desensitized to or tolerated egg. | 54% (20/37) OIT passed OFC to 10 g raw egg and introduced into the diet. | Desensitization: 21/37 had symptoms. 5 reactions required epinephrine. 1 patient withdrew with eosinophilic esophagitis. |
Caminiti et al. 2015 55 | Dried egg white. | 31 | 4–10 years. | RCT, placebo control, double blind (OIT/placebo). | 1 cooked egg twice weekly | 94% (16/17) OIT, 0% control (0/14) desensitized (passed DBPCFC 4 g). | After 6 months of egg diet then 3 months avoidance, 29% (5/17) OIT, 7% (1/14) placebo had sustained tolerance (DBPCFC). | Desensitization: 3 patients had adverse events, 1 discontinued OIT. Egg containing diet phase: 2 patients had symptoms. |
Escudero et al. 201554 | Dried egg white. | 61 | 5–17 years. | RCT, open label (OIT/egg avoidance). | 1 undercooked egg every 2 days and egg ad lib | 93% (28/30) on OIT desensitized. At 4 months, 37% OIT passed DBPCFC 2808 mg (11/25 challenged); 1% control passed DBPCFC (1/31 challenged). | After 1 month avoidance, 37% OIT, 3% control had sustained unresponsiveness (DBPCFC 2808 mg). | 145 reactions in OIT, 14% in dose escalation, 54% in buildup, 31% in maintenance. 70% of patients had ?1 reaction. 1 required epinephrine. |
Ruiz-Garcia et al. 201277 | Dried egg white – OVODES NM kit. | 17 | 6–38 years. | Open-label, not controlled. | 3 eggs per week | 82% (14/17) reached maintenance dose and tolerated for 9 months. | N/A | 70.5% (12/17) symptomatic during OIT. 3 required epinephrine during up-dosing or at home. |
Tortajada et al. 201278 | Raw e79gg. | 19 | 3–14 years. | Open-label, prospective, no control. | 0.5 egg twice weekly for several months, then 1 egg weekly. | 89% (17/19) desensitized to 30 g, no control. | N/A | 2/19 had anaphylactic reactions requiring epinephrine, discontinued OIT. |
Ojeda et al. 201280 | Raw egg. | 31 | 6–15 years. | Open-label, controlled (not randomized). | 0.5 raw (pasteurized) egg 3 times weekly. | 81% (25/31) in OIT reached maximum dose, 74% passed OFC for 1 unpasteurized egg. 3% partially desensitized, 10% not desensitized but increased reactivity threshold. Control outcomes N/A. | N/A | 74% of OIT patients reacted. 180 adverse events, 86% were grades 1–2. 4 required epinephrine at home. |
Letran et al. 201279 | Raw egg. | 17 | 4–14 years. | Open label, not controlled. | 1 egg omelet (or fraction tolerated) | 35% (6–17) fully desensitized. | N/A | Up-dosing: 4 reactions reported. Maintenance: 47% (8/17) had mild symptoms, 1 patient required emergency room visit. |
Meglio et al. 201381 | Raw egg. | 20 | 4–14 years. | RCT, open label (OIT/egg-free diet) | Raw egg or food with eggs 3 times/week | 80% (8/10) OIT, 0% control tolerated 25 mL (13.6 g) daily; 10% OIT had partial tolerance. | N/A | 7/10 OIT had some symptoms during desensitization, 5 resolved, 1 tolerated limited amounts, 1 discontinued. |
Dello Iacono et al. 201282 | Raw egg. | 20 | 5–11 years. | RCT, open label (OIT/egg free diet) | 10–40 mL egg daily. | After 6 months, 0% (0/10) in egg OIT desensitized to 1 raw egg (40 mL); 90% partially desensitized (tolerated 10–40 mL). 0% control passed DBPCFC. | N/A | 100% OIT patients had 53 total adverse events during desensitization. 24% were grades 1–2. None required epinephrine. 30% control patients had 5 total adverse reactions from accidental egg ingestion. |
Vazquez-Ortiz et al. 201456 | Raw egg. | 82 | 5–18 years | Non-randomized, controlled, open label. (Parallel OIT/avoidance). | 1 egg twice weekly | Desensitization: 80% (40/50) OIT reached 2 eggs/week. | At 12 months of maintenance, 56% (28/50) OIT passed OFC for 1 raw egg, 8% (4/50) of OIT partially desensitized (tolerated 0.8–1.7 g). 16% (5/32) of control spontaneously developed tolerance at 12 months (passed DBPCFC). | Dose-related reactions in 45/50 (90%) and 7.6% (1024/13,551) of egg-OIT doses. 61% were mild (grades 1–2), 18 required epinephrine (in 13 patients). |
Garcia-Rodriguez et al. 201183 | Raw and cooked egg. | 23 | 5–17 years. | Open-label, no control. | 1 cooked egg daily for 3 months, then every 2–3 days for 12 months. | 87% (20/23) OIT desensitized (tolerated 1 cooked egg), 61% (14/23) within 5 days. | 2 patients (9%) who failed initial desensitization switched to slow protocol, desensitized in 60–80 days. | 78% (18/23) had an allergic reaction during desensitization. Total reactions 55, 35 mild and 20 moderate. 2 patients had reactions during daily cooked egg maintenance. |
Morisset et al. 200751 | Hard-boiled egg. | 84 | 1–8 years. | RCT (OIT/egg-free diet). (Both egg and milk in the same study). | Daily intake including creamy desserts and flan | 69% OIT (32/49), 51% (18/35) control patients desensitized and passed SBPCFC (7 g raw egg white). | N/A | N/A |
Itoh et al. 201084 | Scrambled egg. | 6 | 7–12 years. | Open-label, no control. | 1 heated whole egg twice weekly | 100% desensitized to 1 scrambled egg (60 g), meantime 12 days, 50% also passed OFC 1 g powdered egg after 9–12 months maintenance. | 16–21 months after rush desensitization, all continuing to eat 1 heated egg twice weekly. | 100% had allergic symptoms during desensitization. None required epinephrine. |
Leonard et al. 201285 | Baked egg. | 70 | 0.5–25 years. | Prospective, historical control. | 1–3 servings of baked egg product daily | 53% (42/70) tolerated partially cooked egg (OFC 6.5 g), 36% (28/70) did not but continued baked egg. | Retrospective: 28% (13/47) tolerant to partially cooked egg, 13% (6/47) to baked egg, 59% (28/47) avoidant. | No reactions to baked egg consumption, 1 patient reacted to accidental exposure to unbaked egg. |