Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Mar 1.
Published in final edited form as: Br J Dev Psychol. 2018 Jul 23;37(1):51–67. doi: 10.1111/bjdp.12253

Table 2.

Stability Across Time by Moderator Groups

Activity level (years) Emotionality (years) Shyness (years) Sociability (years)
3 → 5 5 → 6 3 → 6 3 → 5 5 → 6 3 → 6 3 → 5 5 → 6 3 → 6 3 → 5 5 → 6 3 → 6
Child Gender
 Girls .60a .70 .55 .60 .69 .54 .62 .72 .55a .51 .58 .45
 Boys .62b .71 .56 .58 .69 .53 .65 .74 .59b .51 .61 .46
Child Birth Order
 Firstborns .62 .72 .56 .57 .68 .53 .65 .74 .58 .50 .58a .45
 Laterborns .61 .71 .56 .61 .70 .55 .62 .73 .56 .51 .61b .47
Child Term Status
 Term .61 .71 .56 .59 .69 .54 .63 .73 .57 .51 .60 .45
 Preterm .65 .73 .55 .54 .65 .42 .66 .78 .65 .54 .58 .53
Maternal Age
 <20 .44 .60a .38 .53a .63 .43a .54 .71 .46 .48 .64 .43
 ≥ 20 & <30 .60 .70b .55 .56b .67 .52a .63 .73 .58 .49 .59 .45
 ≥ 30 & <40 .64 .74c .58 .62c .71 .57b .64 .73 .57 .54 .61 .47
 ≥ 40 .55 .65abc .49 .62abc .67 .60ab .62 .69 .53 .57 .51 .42
Maternal Education
 At or below O Level .59a .69 .55 .57a .68 .53 .62a .72 .56 .49a .58a .43a
 Above O level .63b .73 .57 .61b .69 .55 .66b .74 .59 .54b .62b .50b
Maternal Anxietya
 Normal .62 .71 .57 .58 .68 .53 .64 .73 .57 .51 .60 .45
 High Levels of Anxiety .59 .72 .53 .53 .66 .47 .61 .73 .56 .50 .60 .51
Maternal Depressionb
 Normal .62 .72 .57 .58 .68 .53 .64 .73 .57 .50 .60 .45
 High Levels of Depression .59 .68 .53 .54 .68 .52 .59 .72 .54 .54 .63 .53

Note. Stability estimates are all significant, ps < .001. Coefficients in bold and with different subscripts within moderators and time intervals are significantly different from one another.

a

A cut-off point ≥ 8 on the anxiety scale of CCEI was used: 6,578 mothers were normal, and 1,461 mothers had high levels of anxiety.

b

A cut-off point ≥ 13 on EPDS was used: 7,094 mothers were normal, and 943 mothers had high levels of depressive symptoms.