Skip to main content
. 2019 Jan 28;14(1):e0211317. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0211317

Table 6. Results of the STFM estimation of time-varying and persistent technical efficiency VAT and VAT gap using the model of Kumbhakar, Lien and Hardaker [8] for EU-26, 2000–2015.

Country Time-varying efficiency of VAT in % Time-varying VAT gap
in %
Persistent efficiency of VAT in % Persistent VAT gap in % Overall Technical Efficiency of VAT in % Overall VAT gap in % CASE VAT gap average
2000–2015
Austria 96.56 3.44 96.21 3.79 92.89 7.11 10.23
Belgium 96.53 3.47 94.23 5.77 90.96 9.04 12.48
Bulgaria 94.95 5.05 86.05 13.95 81.70 18.30 18.66
Czech Republic 95.21 4.79 84.50 15.50 80.45 19.55 20.96
Denmark 96.62 3.38 96.34 3.66 93.09 6.91 10.08
Estonia 96.01 3.99 91.10 8.90 87.46 12.54 13.44
Finland 96.29 3.71 95.88 4.12 92.33 7.67 10.33
France 96.40 3.60 94.45 5.55 91.05 8.95 13.39
Germany 96.57 3.43 96.13 3.87 92.84 7.16 11.73
Greece 95.94 4.06 76.73 23.27 73.61 26.39 28.83
Hungary 95.98 4.02 81.97 18.03 78.68 21.32 23.48
Ireland 96.15 3.85 96.51 3.49 92.79 7.21 9.27
Italy 96.25 3.75 80.08 19.92 77.08 22.92 26.76
Latvia 94.59 5.41 81.56 18.44 77.14 22.86 22.44
Lithuania 95.34 4.66 71.54 28.46 68.20 31.80 32.69
Luxembourg 96.16 3.84 96.29 3.71 92.60 7.40 8.47
Malta 92.15 7.85 79.86 20.14 73.59 26.41 22.85
Netherlands 96.47 3.53 98.38 1.62 94.91 5.09 6.35
Poland 95.27 4.73 89.08 10.92 84.86 15.14 17.13
Portugal 96.02 3.98 96.29 3.71 92.46 7.54 9.66
Romania 95.18 4.82 64.31 35.69 61.21 38.79 40.28
Slovakia 95.59 4.41 75.81 24.19 72.47 27.53 28.97
Slovenia 96.56 3.44 97.61 2.39 94.26 5.74 6.50
Spain 95.22 4.78 96.57 3.43 91.95 8.05 9.99
Sweden 96.59 3.41 98.93 1.07 95.56 4.44 3.52
United Kingdom 96.57 3.43 96.09 3.91 92.80 7.20 11.59
EU-26 average 95.81 4.19 88.94 11.06 85.27 14.73 16.54

Source: Own calculation and the reports of CASE [1, 2, 3, 4].