Skip to main content
. 2019 Jan 29;9:833. doi: 10.1038/s41598-018-37386-w

Table 1.

Characteristics of included studies.

First author Year Country Ethnicity Genotype method NOS score Hearing loss type Case Control GST T1 GST M1
Case Control Case Control
WT null WT null WT null WT null
Manche 2016 India Indian Multiplex-PCR 8 ARHL 220 270 119 101 202 68 121 99 201 69
Zhu 2011 China Chinese Multiplex-PCR 8 ARHL 110 114 61 49 58 56 39 71 33 81
Bared 2010 USA Mixed Multiplex-PCR 8 ARHL 55 79 21 31 52 27 16 36 41 38
Ates 2005 Turkey Turkish Real-time PCR 8 ARHL 68 69 54 14 53 16 36 32 40 29
Shen 2012 China Chinese PCR-RFLP 8 NIHL 444 445 215 229 210 235 198 246 253 192
Abreu-Silva 2011 Brazil Brazilian PCR-RFLP 8 NIHL 151 104 40 111 22 82 115 36 77 27
Liu 2006 China Chinese PCR 8 NIHL 123 123 58 60 48 66 38 85 54 69
Yang 2005 China Chinese Multiplex-PCR 8 NIHL 93 101 31 62 47 57 37 56 35 66
Carlsson 2005 Sweden Swedish PCR-RFLP 8 NIHL 103 112 90 13 104 8 50 53 59 53
Choeyprasert 2013 Thailand German Multiplex-PCR 8 DIHL 55 13 38 17 4 9 24 31 5 8
Jurajda 2012 Czech Czechs PCR 7 DIHL 12 26 10 2 20 6 4 8 10 16
Palodetto 2010 Brazil Brazilian Multiplex-PCR 5 DIHL 10 20 8 2 13 7 6 4 11 9
Barahmani 2009 USA Mixed Multiplex-PCR 7 DIHL 19 15 13 6 10 5 11 8 9 6
Oldenburg 2007 Norway Norwegians Multiplex-PCR 7 DIHL 89 84 75 14 70 14 49 40 45 39
Peters 2000 Germany Thai PCR 8 DIHL 19 20 12 8 16 3 11 9 8 11
Um 2011 Korea Korean Multiplex-PCR 6 SSHL 98 343 51 47 173 170 40 58 138 205
Cadoni 2006 Italy Italian Multiplex-PCR 8 SSHL 80 80 60 20 62 18 41 39 36 44

NOS: Newcastle-Ottawa Scale. GST: glutathione s-transferase. ARHL: age-related hearing loss. NIHL: noise-induced hearing loss. DIHL: drug-induced hearing loss. SSHL: sudden sensorineural hearing loss. WT: wild type. PCR-RFLP: polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphis.